£1m pay-off for Yorkshire councils over phone masts
Published Date:
21 March 2008
By Jonathan Reed Political Editor
DOZENS of mobile phone masts set up at schools, libraries, leisure centres and homes across Yorkshire brought in nearly £1m in revenue for local councils last year.
Campaigners fear the masts could cause long-term health effects, following claims of cancer clusters around masts in other parts of the country, despite Government assurances that they are safe.
Last night there were calls for councils to stop putting up masts at sensitive locations until further studies conclusively proved there were no dangers.
Using the Freedom of Information Act, the Yorkshire Post has discovered that at least 131 mobile phone masts are located on council properties across the region, netting councils £997,942 in rent last year.
In Leeds, the city council made £410,000 in rent from 39 masts, including blocks of flats such as Queenswood Heights in Headingley and Gledhow Towers in Potternewton, while Hull City Council earned £259,044.
York City Council is among the authorities which make money from putting masts on schools – there are two at Huntington School and one at Milthorpe School, while it also benefits from a mast at Edmund Wilson Swimming Pool.
The Government says there is no evidence of health risks from mobile phones and masts and all masts have to conform to safety standards. However, in the Midlands, hundreds of residents in Stoke-on-Trent are campaigning for a mast on top of a block of flats to be taken down amid concern it could be responsible for numerous health problems, including deaths, since it was approved in 1993.
A spokesman for the anti-mast campaign group Mast Sanity – which fears long-term health effects from the mast – said: "I think it's entirely irresponsible of a council or Government office in this day and age to put something like that on their land."
Leeds North West MP Greg Mulholland said: "I think the idea that we should let mobile phone masts be put up around the place because there's no proven threat to health is really a topsy-turvy way of looking at things.
"I believe more work must be done and until it's proven there are no health risks we should avoid them being near schools, hospitals and homes.
"The mobile phone companies have had it their own way for far too long. While we all accept mobile communication is important I think we need to give communities a better say in planning them – people will have more confidence this is not just a money-making device."
Skipton and Ripon MP David Curry, who introduced a Bill in 2006 to give more planning controls over mast locations, said: "Everybody wants perfect reception but they don't want the mast that delivers it. I think the common-sense approach is to look for a site that does not lead to offence and doesn't raise sensitivities. If that can be done without going to places like schools, that's fine."
A City of York Council spokeswoman said when requests had come forward in the past they had approached the governing body of the school in question and asked for their views.
"The application only goes forward with their approval. Any income from the siting of the mast goes to the school in question," she said.
Leeds City Council also said residents were approached if mobile phone company wanted to put a mast on a council tower block. The income from the mast is used to manage and maintain the blocks.
"If they object, the company will have to seek an alternative site," the spokesman said.
"This is just one stage of the consultation – should the residents be happy with the proposals then local councillors are asked for their comments and, finally, the plans are submitted for planning permission, which is governed by strict planning rules relating to the design and location of the mast."
A spokesman for the Mobile Operators Association said: "More than 30 authoritative expert scientific reviews undertaken both in the UK and around the world, including by the World Health Organisation, during the past seven years have not found adverse health effects for adults or children caused by mobile phone base stations operating within the international health and safety guidelines used in the United Kingdom.
"Local authority sites increase the number of possible locations available to operators and makes it easier to find suitable sites. Local authorities can then use the money for public services, hospitals or old people's homes or maintaining housing blocks."
Yorkshire breakdown by local authority:
Income stated is per annum
Barnsley
Companies paying mast rental:
Vodafone - £4,000
Orange - £6,000
T Mobile - £6,500
Total income: £16,500
Mast locations:
Roebuck Hill Recreation Ground, Platts Common - Vodafone
Wombwell High School, Roebuck Street - Orange
Albion House, Union Street - T Mobile
Bradford
Companies paying mast rental:
T Mobile
Orange
Vodafone
Total income: £45,958.50
Mast locations:
Eccleshill Pool, Harrogate Road, - T Mobile
Towngate Wyke - Orange
Central Library, Princes's Way - Vodafone
Central Library, Prince's Way - T Mobile
Leaventhorpe Middle School, Chelwood Drive - Orange
Land at Cliffe Lane, Baildon - Orange
Calderdale
None
Craven
None
Doncaster
Companies paying mast rental:
Orange
BT
Vodafone
T Mobile
Transcom UK
O2
West Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive
Total income: £72,871.75
Mast locations:
Rossington High School - Orange £5,000
Mexborough High School - Orange £1,738
Mexborough nurseries - T Mobile (formerly One2One) £3,500
Council House - BT/ Vodafone/ T Mobile/ Transcom UK/ O2/ WYPTE (total: £49,383.75)
Bentley ITEC - Orange £3,500
Racecourse - Orange £8,000
East Riding
None
Hambleton
None
Harrogate
Companies paying mast rental:
O2 - £4,500
T Mobile (formerly One2One) - £3,945
Total income: £8,445
Mast locations:
Rudfarlington Farm, Wetherby Road - O2
Land at Claro Road, Harrogate - One2One
Hull
Companies paying mast rental:
Hutchison 3G
Vodafone
Orange
O2
T Mobile
Humberside Police Authority
Cable and Wireless
Total income: £259,044.20
Mast locations:
Barham Road, Ross Cleveland House - Hutchison 3G
Bayswater Court 1 - O2
Bayswater Court 1 - T Mobile
Bayswater Court 1 - Hutchison 3G
Denaby Court 1 - Orange
Denaby Court 1 - T Mobile
Gatwick House 1 - T Mobile
Gatwick House 1 - Vodafone
Gatwick House 1 - Hutchison 3G
George Street multi-storey car park - Hutchison 3G
Gorthorpe Flats - Hutchison 3G
Great Thornton Street - T Mobile
Great Thornton Street - Humberside Police Authority
Highcourt - Orange
Homethorpe - Vodafone
King Street - Orange
Lindsey Place - T Mobile
Milldane - Humberside Police Authority
Milldane - T Mobile
Millport Drive - Hutchison 3G
Muswell Court 1 - Orange
Muswell Court 1 - Vodafone
Osborne Street multi-storey car park - Hutchison 3G
Padstow House 1 - Orange
Padstow House 1 - O2
Pryme Street multi-storey - Vodafone
Pryme Street multi-storey - Hutchison 3G
Torpoint Drive - Orange
Valiant Drive - T Mobile
Valiant Drive - Orange
Woolwich Drive - T Mobile
Gorthorpe Flats - Vodafone
Kingston House - Cable and Wireless
Kingston House - Orange
Kingston House - T Mobile
Kirklees
Companies paying mast rental:
Orange - £25,216
O2 - £27,238
BT - £3,750
Vodafone - £19,496
Arqiva - £8,950
T Mobile - £6,500
Total income: £91,150
Mast locations:
Almondbury High School and Language College, Fernside Avenue - Orange, £6,657
Almondbury High School and Language College, Fernside Avenue - O2, £6,750
Batley Business and Enterprise College, Batley Field Hill - British Telecoms, £3,750
Batley Business and Enterprise College, Batley Field Hill - Vodafone, £8,250
Batley Business and Enterprise College, Batley Field Hill - O2, £8,750
Colne Valley High School, Gillroyd Lane, Linthwaite - Vodafone, £6,750
Rawthorpe High School, Nether Hall Avenue - Orange, £6,300
Crow Lane Junior, Infants and Nursery School, Crow Lane, Milnsbridge - Arqiva, £1,950
Buxton House, Albion Street, Huddersfield - O2, £6,500
The Deighton Centre, Deighton Road - T Mobile, £6500
Land at Fell Greave Wood, Bradford Road, Bradley - Orange, £6,000
Land at Bradley Wood, Bradley - Vodafone, £4496
Land at Bradley Wood, Bradley - O2, £5238
Land at Hart Street, Newsome, Huddersfield - Arqiva, £7000
Land Adjoining 141 Leeds Road, Birstall - Orange, £2259
Land Adjoining National Grid Pylon, Huddersfield Road, Fixby - Orange, £4000
Leeds
Companies paying mast rental:
Orange - £140,000
Vodafone - £114,000
T-Mobile - £68,000
O2 - £42,500
Hutchison - £32,000
Crown Castle - £9,000
Arquiva - £4,500
Total income: - £410,000
Mast location and property use:
Marlborough Towers, Little London - residential
Grayson Heights, Eden Mount, Kirkstall - residential
Queenswood Heights, Queenswood Drive, Headingley - residential
Clayton Court, Clayton Road, Stourton - residential
Lovell Park Towers, Lovell Park Road, Little London - residential
Potternewton Playing Fields, Potternewton Lane, Chapel Allerton - residential
Potternewton Heights, Potternewton Lane, Potternewton - residential
Gledhow Towers, Gledhow Lane, Potternewton - residential
Lidgett Towers, Lidgett Lane, Potternewton - residential
Shakespeare Towers, Shakespeare Approach Burmantofts - residential
Gipton Gate West, Gipton - residential
Gipton Gate East, Gipton - residential
Middleton Road, Middleton - residential
South Point, South Accommodation Rd, Hunslet - offices
Meynell Heights, Meynell Approach, Holbeck - residential
Cottingley Towers, Cottingley Drive, Cottingley - residential
Holbeck Towers, Holbeck Lane, Holbeck - residential
Gaitskell Grange - residential
Whincover Grange, Whincover Drive, Wortley - residential
Burnsall Grange, Theaker Lane, Moor Top - residential
Burnsall Gardens, Theaker Lane, Moor Top - residential
Beecroft Hill, Broad Lane, Bramley - residential
The Heights East, Heights Way, Armley - residential
The Heights West, Heights Way, Armley - residential
Poplar Mount, Poplar Way, Stanningley - residential
Barncroft Grange, Barncroft Drive, Seacroft - residential
Barncroft Court, Barncroft Drive, Seacroft - residential
Barncroft Heights, Barncroft Drive, Seacroft - residential
Barncroft Towers, Barncroft Drive, Seacroft - residential
Elmete Towers, Elmete Drive, Oakwood - residential
Parkway Towers, Parkway, Gildersome - residential
Parkway Grange, Parkway, Gildersome - residential
Queensview, Queenswood Drive, Headingley - residential
Sherburn Court, Sherburn Approach, Swarcliffe - residential
Seacroft Gate, Brooklands Avenue, Seacroft - residential
Lakeland Court, Lakeland Drive, Alwoodley - residential
Norman Towers, Kirkstall - residential
Leafield Towers, Leafield Grange, Moortown - residential
Clayton Court, Clayton Road, Stourton - residential
North Yorkshire
Rental paid per district:
Scarborough - £4500 pa
Minskip - £4336 pa
East Ayton - £4336 pa
Total income: £13,172
Rotherham
Companies paying mast rental:
Vodafone - £11,000
Orange - £9500
T Mobile (formerly One2One) - £6,250
Total income: £26,750
Mast locations:
Maltby Sports Centre, off Braithwell Road, Maltby - Vodafone £5000
Beeversleigh, Clifton Lane - Orange £7000
Oaks Lane Depot, Kimberworth Park - T Mobile (formerly One2One) £6250
Oaks Lane Depot, Kimberworth Park - Vodafone £6000
Land off Haugh Road, Rawmarsh(former baths site) - Orange (formerly Hutchinson Microtel) £2500
Rydedale
Ryedale District Council Depot, Showfield Lane, Malton - National Grid Wireless, formerly known as Crown Castle UK Ltd
Total income: £3,838.64
Scarborough
None
Sheffield
No response
Wakefield
Companies paying mast rental:
Orange - £6,723
Vodafone - £2,274
T Mobile - £4,000
Total income: £12,997
Mast locations:
Hemsworth High School, Station Road, Hemsworth - Orange
Minsthorpe Community College, Minsthorpe Lane, South Kirkby - Vodafone
Lodge Hill Farm, Wakefield Road, Ossett - T Mobile
York
Companies paying rental for masts:
Orange
T Mobile
Vodafone
Total income: £33,217
Mast locations:
Edmund Wilson Swimming Pool - Orange
Huntington School - Orange
Huntington School - T-mobile
Millthorpe School - Vodafone
Museum Street council offices - Vodafone
Parliament Street (within traffic light) - Orange
The full article contains 1798 words and appears in n/a newspaper.
-
Last Updated:
25 March 2008 9:26 AM
-
Source:
n/a
-
Location:
Yorkshire