Bake-off face-off: How do Mary Berry and Prue Leith compare?

Television cook Prue Leith is set to replace Mary Berry as a judge on The Great British Bake Off, according to reports.
Prue Leith (left) and Mary BerryPrue Leith (left) and Mary Berry
Prue Leith (left) and Mary Berry

The former Great British Menu judge will appear alongside Paul Hollywood when the hit show moves to Channel 4 later this year, if the reports are confirmed.

Leith, 76, is reportedly seen as a “like for like” replacement for Berry, who chose to stay with the BBC along with hosts Mel Giedroyc and Sue Perkins.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But how do the two cooks measure up against each other? Here are their vital ingredients...

Age - Leith is five years 81-year-old Berry’s junior at 76.

Training - Berry studied catering and institutional management at Bath College of Domestic Science, then took a job working at Bath’s electricity board showroom, where she would visit homes of customers who had bought new electric ovens and bake a Victoria sponge to demonstrate how they worked.

She later moved to London, where she worked for the Dutch Dairy Bureau, taking college courses in the evenings, and eventually studied at the French Le Cordon Bleu cookery school.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Leith trained at Le Cordon Bleu’s cookery school in London and set up a catering company making lunches for businesses before launching her career as a restaurateur.

Career - Berry was a recipe tester at a PR firm and became the food editor of Housewife magazine in 1966, then held the same post at Ideal Home from 1970 to 1973.

Leith opened her Michelin-starred restaurant, Leith’s, in 1969 and then her chef training college Leith’s School of Food and Wine in 1975.

She sold the school in 1993 and the restaurant in 1995, founding the Prue Leith Chef’s Academy in her home country of South Africa in the same year.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

TV Work - Berry was a judge on The Great British Bake Off from 2010 to 2016 and has been the star of various other BBC cooking series including The Great British Food Revival, Mary Berry Cooks, Mary Berry’s Absolute Favourites, and will present a new programme called Mary Berry Everyday.

Leith’s best-known TV role was as a judge on The Great British Menu from 2006 to 2016, and has made appearances as a guest judge on MasterChef in South Africa.

Cookbooks - Berry has published more than 70 cookbooks since her first in 1970, and sold over five million copies. She also released her autobiography, Recipe For Life, in 2013.

Leith is lagging behind Berry with 12 cookbooks, although she has also written seven novels and her memoir, Relish, was published in 2012.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Awards - Berry was awarded a CBE in 2012 and won a National Television Award in 2017 for the best TV judge in her role on The Great British Bake Off.

Leith was given an OBE in 1989 and a CBE in 2010.

Quotes - Berry on leaving The Great British Bake Off: “What a privilege and honour it has been to be part of seven years of magic in a tent - The Great British Bake Off. The Bake Off family, Paul, Mel and Sue, have given me so much joy and laughter.

“My decision to stay with the BBC is out of loyalty to them, as they have nurtured me, and the show, that was a unique and brilliant format from day one. I am just sad for the audience who may not be ready for change, I hope they understand my decision.”

Leith on leaving The Great British Menu: “From the first Great British Menu for the Queen’s 80th birthday to honouring those who fought on D-Day, I’ve been repeatedly amazed at the inventiveness and skill of the chefs.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“I am very proud of the banquets we’ve put together. However, with 11 banquets under my belt in more ways than one, I think it’s time for a change and, with much hesitation, I’ve decided to relinquish my seat in the judging chamber.”