After two years and £800,000, South Yorkshire Police’s botched sex abuse probe against Cliff Richard comes to nothing

Sir Cliff Richard is to face no further action following the South Yorkshire Police investigation into allegations of historical sexual abuse, it has been announced.
Sir Cliff Richard is to face no further action following the South Yorkshire Police investigation into allegations of historical sexual abuse, it has been announced.
0
Have your say

Sir Cliff Richard is to face no further action following the South controversial Yorkshire Police investigation into allegations of historical sexual abuse.

The Crown Prosecution Service said there was “insufficient evidence to prosecute” the 75-year-old singer.

Martin Goldman, Chief Crown Prosecutor for Yorkshire and Humberside, said: “The CPS has carefully reviewed evidence relating to claims of non-recent sexual offences dating between 1958 and 1983 made by four men.

Hillsborough, Rotherham, Cliff Richard and the Rhino Whip Affair: Five police scandals in South Yorkshire

Cliff Richard: Timeline of South Yorkshire Police’s ‘inept’ sex abuse probe

“We have decided that there is insufficient evidence to prosecute.

Charters Estate in Sunningdale, Berkshire, where Sir Cliff Richard has an apartment

Charters Estate in Sunningdale, Berkshire, where Sir Cliff Richard has an apartment

“This decision has been made in accordance with the Code for Crown Prosecutors and our guidance for prosecutors on cases of sexual offences.

Sir Cliff said he was “obviously thrilled that the vile accusations and the resulting investigation have finally been brought to a close”.

South Yorkshire Police faced ridicule when Sir Cliff’s home was searched. The controversy surrounded a deal the force struck with the BBC which led to aerial footage of the raid being screened on live TV, leading to claims that police tipped off TV producers. An independent report found the force had “interfered with his privacy and may well have caused unnecessary distress”.

Chief Constable David Crompton was accused by MPs of incompetence over his force’s handling of the affair. Mr Crompton, who was later suspended, said an investigation had failed to identify the source of the leak to the BBC.

Today, Sir Cliff said: “After almost two years under police investigation I learnt today that they have finally closed their enquiries.

“I have always maintained my innocence, co-operated fully with the investigation, and cannot understand why it has taken so long to get to this point!

“Nevertheless, I am obviously thrilled that the vile accusations and the resulting investigation have finally been brought to a close.

“Ever since the highly-publicised and BBC-filmed raid on my home I have chosen not to speak publicly. Even though I was under pressure to ‘speak out’, other than to state my innocence, which was easy for me to do as I have never molested anyone in my life, I chose to remain silent.”

Cliff ‘won’t return’ to home raided by Yorkshire police

South Yorkshire Police - which claims to have spent £800,000 investigating Sir Cliff - said today it “apologised wholeheartedly” for its “initial handling of the media interest” in its investigation.

It added: “Following an initial allegation received by the force in April 2014, South Yorkshire detectives have explored and gathered all information available and carried out a thorough and detailed investigation, which has covered the UK and abroad.

“The investigation, which has spanned two years, is estimated to have cost in the region of £800,000, including staffing costs.

“After careful consideration of the evidence provided to them, the CPS has concluded that no further action should be taken against the man due to there being insufficient evidence to prosecute.

“A further five allegations considered by the investigation team did not meet the threshold for referral to CPS for a charging decision.

“South Yorkshire Police accept the decision of the CPS in this case and all those involved have been informed.”

The force said it had “implemented the learning” from a review conducted by former Chief Constable Andy Trotter.

Mr Goldman said the CPS had “carefully reviewed evidence relating to claims of non-recent sexual offences dating between 1958 and 1983 made by four men”.

He added: “We have decided that there is insufficient evidence to prosecute.

“This decision has been made in accordance with the Code for Crown Prosecutors and our guidance for prosecutors on cases of sexual offences.

“The CPS worked with police during the investigation. This has helped minimise the time needed to reach a decision once we received the complete file of evidence on 10 May.”

As well as criticism for the investigation into Sir Cliff, South Yorkshire Police has been accused of corruption and incompetence over its reaction to the Hillsborough stadium disaster, Rotherham sex abuse case and Orgreave miners’ strike.

Publicity of the investigation has fuelled calls for those accused of sex offences to remain anonymous until they are charged or convicted.

Sir Cliff, who was never charged, has consistently denied any wrongdoing but has not spoken publicly about the case until now.

“This was despite the widely-shared sense of injustice resulting from the high-profile fumbling of my case from day one,” his statement continued.

“Other than in exceptional cases, people who are facing allegations should never be named publicly until charged.

“I was named before I was even interviewed and for me that was like being hung out like ‘live bait’. It is obvious that such strategies simply increase the risk of attracting spurious claims which not only tie up police resources and waste public funds, but they forever tarnish the reputations of innocent people.

“There have been numerous occasions in recent years where this has occurred, and I feel very strongly that no innocent person should be treated in this way.

“I know the truth and in some peoples’ eyes the CPS’s announcement today doesn’t go far enough because it doesn’t expressly state that I am innocent; which of course I am. There lies the problem.

“My reputation will not be fully vindicated because the CPS’s policy is to only say something general about there being ‘insufficient’ evidence.

“How can there be evidence for something that never took place! This is also a reason why people should never be named publicly until they have been charged unless there are exceptional circumstances.

“To my fans and members of the public, to the press and media, all of whom continued to show me such encouraging and wonderful support, I would like to say ‘thank you’ it would have been so much harder without you.”

The singer, actor and TV star has enjoyed a career spanning 57 years.

Britain’s greatest solo hit-maker, his output of hundreds of hit singles and albums is unlikely to be equalled.

His greatest hits include chart-toppers such as The Young Ones, Living Doll, Summer Holiday, We Don’t Talk Anymore and 1988 Christmas number one Mistletoe And Wine.