Child safety grilling angers burger van man

His customers can be anyone from a plumber to a salesman and just occasionally a family stop for a bite.

Yet caterer Paul St Clair is the latest to have to undergo criminal checks usually required for those working with children and vulnerable adults.

Mr St Clair, 50, who trades from a layby off a busy road in East Yorkshire, has just completed his second Criminal Records Bureau check in a year, a situation a local MP described yesterday as “just the most recent example of the growing misuse of these checks.”

The pressure group Liberty said councils did not have the power to demand checks on street traders “in such a random way.”

The former lorry driver who racked up nearly 30 years driving all over Europe said he was stunned when first told last July he’d have to have the check.

The catering van is less than a mile from Bishop Burton College, but Mr St Clair said there was no passing trade from children.

Each CRB check has cost him just under £50, including £15 for an identification badge, a situation which Mr St Clair said would not be so bad if there was a level playing field.

He said: “I don’t mind provided everyone else has to do it. Sweetshop owners don’t need one and yet they are the ones who deal with children.

“You can stand in the market at Beverley and do exactly what I do but you don’t need to meet the same stringent checks.

“If you have a daily licence you don’t need one. It just shows there’s no level across the board – it’s all to pot.

“If we get a child, which is rarely, they are usually in the arms of their mum or dad.

“It goes on - if you go into McDonald’s and a 16-year-old serves you, do you need one?”

He added: “We’ve had police who pulled up here and health and hygiene people who just can’t believe it – it’s bureaucracy gone mad.”

“I think it is just basically another money-making scheme to justify people’s jobs.”

East Riding Council said it had consulted on changes to its Street Trading Policy, which was implemented last July, and there had been no objections.

However Beverley and Holderness MP Graham Stuart said he was concerned about the proliferation of Criminal Records Bureau checks.