Critics have their say on Downton Abbey film shot in Yorkshire

Downton Abbey's much-anticipated cinematic adaptation has arrived and critics have had their say on Julian Fellowes' period drama.
From left, Harry Hadden-Paton, Laura Carmichael, Hugh Bonneville and Michael Fox, right, in a scene from Downton Abbey. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)From left, Harry Hadden-Paton, Laura Carmichael, Hugh Bonneville and Michael Fox, right, in a scene from Downton Abbey. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)
From left, Harry Hadden-Paton, Laura Carmichael, Hugh Bonneville and Michael Fox, right, in a scene from Downton Abbey. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)

The hugely popular TV series aired on ITV from 2010 to 2015 and followed the fortunes of the aristocratic Crawley family and their downstairs servants at a Yorkshire country estate.

Read More
The royal visit to a Yorkshire stately home that inspired the new Downton Abbey ...

The film was produced with the help of Screen Yorkshire and shot at locations including Harewood House in Leeds.

Jim Carter as Mr Carson in the film, due for release in the UK on September 13. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)Jim Carter as Mr Carson in the film, due for release in the UK on September 13. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)
Jim Carter as Mr Carson in the film, due for release in the UK on September 13. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It kicks off in 1927, shortly before a royal visit to Downton Abbey by King George V and Queen Mary.

Many of the cast members from the original series have returned, including Dame Maggie Smith, Hugh Bonneville, Laura Carmichael, Jim Carter, Michelle Dockery and Elizabeth McGovern.

After the film's world premiere in London on Monday, the first reviews arrived. Critics are largely united in calling the film a decent, if unspectacular, adaptation.

In a three-star review, the BBC's Caryn James described the film as "delightful fun", despite the plot being "obvious almost to the point of stupidity".

Elizabeth McGovern, left, as Lady Grantham and Hugh Bonneville, as Lord Grantham. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)Elizabeth McGovern, left, as Lady Grantham and Hugh Bonneville, as Lord Grantham. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)
Elizabeth McGovern, left, as Lady Grantham and Hugh Bonneville, as Lord Grantham. (Jaap Buitendijk/Focus Features via AP)
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

She wrote: "No matter. The movie is so sumptuous and enticing that it's possible to overlook its many cinematic flaws. It fulfils the longing not just for a lost age, but for a television show brought back to life."

The Sun's Grant Rollings also awarded Downton three stars.

He said: "It would be easy to criticise Fellowes for turning out what is essentially a two-hour long episode.

"But it was certainly wise not to send the Crawleys on holiday or to have them saving the world."

Viner said the film was "nothing more than an entire series in miniature" but reserved praise for the "lavish production values and meticulous period detail".

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw also gave the film three stars out of five.

He said the "plots are rickety and the characterisation has the depth of a Franklin Mint plate", but conceded the overall film was "quite enjoyable".

The Hollywood Reporter said Downton is "satisfyingly sumptuous" and praised Dame Maggie's performance.

The film gave the veteran actress "a chance to pull some of her most beloved haughty expressions of indignation and bemusement", according to the reviewer.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

While many reviews were generally positive, the New York Post's Johnny Oleksinski was scathing.

He gave the film one-and-a-half stars and said the film adaptation was "forced and unnecessary".

"Julian Fellowes would have been far better off writing another relaxed Christmas special to satisfy fans", Oleksinski wrote.

Downton Abbey is released in UK cinemas on September 13.

Related topics: