An iPhone for a fiver? It’s too good to be true

If the price on one of these looks too good to be true, it probably is
If the price on one of these looks too good to be true, it probably is
Have your say

IT’S a good rule of thumb that if an offer online seems too good to be true, it probably is. Bear that in mind when you’re next offered an iPhone for a fiver.

There is a rash of advertisements on web pages at the moment for electronics and white goods at prices which seem on the surface to be unmissable, and most are put there by the operators of so-called penny auctions.

Differing from “traditional” auction sites like Ebay, where bids are free and you pay only if you win, these sites charge a non-refundable fee for each bid you make. The item for which you are bidding may indeed go for a song, but only to one person; everyone else who bid and lost is out of pocket.

You can’t buy anything on a penny auction for a penny. Instead, you must buy blocks of credits, costing between £30 and £350, and working out at between 10p and 12.5p each. You use up to six credits each time you bid - so if you have ten punts on an item, you’re down at least six quid if you don’t win. The bidding is confusing. Some penny auction sites insist on unique bids – which means you must guess an amount different to any other bidder. If someone else has bid an identical amount, both bids are cancelled and bang goes your credit.

It’s easy to see how penny sites like Madbid, Bid Budgie and Fastbidding make their money: they can cover their costs many times over from the cash they rake in from failed bidders – to whom the whole thing is said to offer the same adrenaline rush as online betting. Have the authorities cottoned on to this? The Office of Fair Trading (now replaced by other quangos) advises consumers to watch for “misleading or fraudulent sites”, without specifying which those might be, and points out penny auctions can be extremely competitive. Games can be open simultaneously to hundreds of players, and there’s a high chance of being pipped after you’ve spent a bundle on multiple bids.

The OFT also points out that automated bulk bidding, which some penny sites openly encourage, can prolong the auction and push up costs quickly. In the event you win an item, you may not be able to return it if you’re dissatisfied, even though penny auctions are technically covered by the Sale of Goods Act. The obvious advice, then, is to always carry a ten foot barge pole when in the vicinity of one of these auctions – easier said than done because the advertising doesn’t always make its purpose clear until it’s too late. Never sign up for anything online unless it’s something you actively went looking for.