Adoption agency’s bid to reject gay couples

A CATHOLIC adoption agency in West Yorkshire has launched legal action for the right to deny its services to gay couples.

Catholic Care wants permission to change its charitable objectives in order that it can lawfully turn down same-sex couples who want to adopt.

The charity, which finds new homes for “hard to place” children in Leeds, said donations would dry up, forcing it to close, if its request was denied.

Gay rights groups have called the action “astonishing”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

At the Upper Tribunal in London, Monica Carss-Frisk QC, for Catholic Care, told Judge Mr Justice Sales that support for the charity from the Catholic community was dependent on it operating in line with the church’s definition of the family.

She said the Roman Catholic Bishop of Leeds had said church collections could not be sanctioned for an “open” adoption service.

Urging the judge to acknowledge the charity’s principled objections to placing children with same-sex couples, she added: “The alternative is that the services are not provided at all, to the detriment of children in need of adoption,”

Lawyers for the Charity Commission say ruling in favour of Catholic Care would breach equality and human rights laws.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But Miss Carss-Frisk argued the commission was focusing on the needs of gay couples instead of children, “putting the interests of the helper before those of the helpless.”.

Ruth Hunt, director of public affairs for gay rights charity Stonewall, said no publicly-funded organisation should be allowed to act on the basis of “narrow organisational prejudice”.

“We shouldn’t forget that it’s children who would lose out if the agency’s bid succeeds,” she said. “Hundreds of children are adopted from care each year by brilliant gay parents offering love, stability and support.

“It’s astonishing that Catholic Care would prefer to have seen those children remain in care.”

The hearing continues.

Related topics: