‘Chariot charge’ left three dead in riot, jury told

Three men who died after a car was deliberately run into them during last summer’s riots were murdered in a modern-day “chariot charge” after days of simmering tensions, a court heard.

Jurors at Birmingham Crown Court were told yesterday that Haroon Jahan, 20, and brothers Shazad Ali, 30, and Abdul Musavir, 31, were hit by a Mazda car during disorder in the Winson Green area of Birmingham in the early hours of August 10, as disorder swept across England.

Loud gasps were heard in the court as CCTV footage of the fatal incident was shown, and the victims’ family members sobbed in the public gallery.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The images clearly show the three men being flung into the air by the impact. They were pronounced dead in hospital.

Prosecutor Tim Spencer QC, who had warned the jury about the “shocking circumstances”, said: “The driving you have just seen was not chance, it was not accidental. It was deliberate and co-ordinated. It was the modern-day equivalent of a chariot charge. And it was deadly.”

Ryan Goodwin, 21, Shaun Flynn, 26, Juan Ruiz-Gaviria, 31, Joshua Donald, 27, Everton Graham, 30, Adam King, 24, Ian Beckford, 30, and Aaron Parkins, 18, all deny three counts of murder.

Jurors heard on the evenings of August 8 and 9 local businesses, including mobile phone shops, a petrol station and a social club, were targeted by rioters.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mr Spencer said the fatal collision followed days of growing tension in the area between gangs of youths in cars and crowds of mostly Asian men from the community.

“All of the men in the dock must have been aware of that backdrop, the backdrop that was the reality of this area of Birmingham over the period we are concerned with.”

Mr Spencer told the court some of a group of between 50 and 100 Asian men on the streets were armed with sticks, batons and bats, and that other members of the Asian group had picked up bricks or rocks after beginning to gather at around 9.30pm on August 9 to prevent looters from targeting local businesses.

Mr Spencer told the court the defendants were in three separate black cars – a Ford Fiesta, a Mazda and an Audi A3 Sport Quattro.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

One witness, he said, described seeing a man shouting from a window of the Mazda: “Pakis, Pakis, we’re coming back for you.”

He said the three cars convened in Dugdale Street, close to the scene of the collision in Dudley Road, moments before.

“It was an opportunity to finalise the plan,” he told the court. “It was an opportunity for those who did not want to go back and ‘get the Pakis’ to leave.

“Here, in Dugdale Street, was an opportunity to say: ‘I want nothing of what is about to happen, let me out of this car’.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“But that is not what happened. All those eight men stayed in one or other of those three cars as they progressed down Dugdale Street and carried out their deadly task.”

The Audi can be seen in the CCTV footage swerving as it travels along the road, while the other two vehicles hold back. Moments later an arm is extended from the driver’s side of the Mazda car.

The prosecutor asked the jury: “Did you see the arm? It is a signal. A signal to those in the Fiesta, particularly the driver, to go.”

Mr Spencer told the court the Audi was driven by King, while Goodwin, Flynn and Ruiz-Gaviria were passengers.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The prosecutor said the Fiesta was driven by Donald, with Parkins as a passenger, and the Mazda was driven by Beckford, with Graham seated in the front passenger seat.

Mr Spencer said “perfectly legitimate questions” could be asked about whether the conduct of some members of the Asian group was lawful.

But he added: “The prosecution are here to put before you what we say was murderous conduct. The prosecution say the driving at the heart of this case, the driving which culminated in three deaths, was out of all sensible proportion to anything that had gone on before.

“That driving was murder and nothing less.”

Goodwin, of Cranford Street, Smethwick; Ruiz-Gaviria, of Coplow Street, Ladywood, Birmingham; Donald, of Kelsall Croft, Ladywood; Beckford, of Quinton, Birmingham; and Graham, King and Flynn, all of no fixed address; were remanded in custody.

Aaron Parkins, whose address was withheld, was bailed to return to the court today.

The trial, which is expected to last up to 10 weeks, was adjourned and will resume today (FRI).

Related topics: