Developer ‘exaggerating’ say gas plant inquiry protesters

A public inquiry heard yesterday from opponents of the proposed processing plant earmarked for a 22-acre site near the North York Moors National Park.

As the hearing continued into its second week, claims were made that the plant would not meet the energy needs of the nation.

But the firm behind the plans, Moorland Energy, is adamant the scheme is vital to ensure Britain has a sustainable supply of natural gas.

The firm’s chief executive, Lawrie Erasmus, told the inquiry: “It will make important and valuable economic and social contributions to the local communities and attract new residents and families into the area.”

He claimed there is a shortfall between domestic gas production and consumption of about 50 per cent, which is forecast to rise to 75 per cent by 2020.

The shortfall would have to be met by an increased dependence on imported gas, Mr Erasmus added.

But opponents have maintained the environment should not be sacrificed at the expense of apparent economic benefits.

North Yorkshire County Council, which is the main planning authority, and the North York Moors National Park Authority have both raised grave concerns over the plans.

Coun Janet Sanderson, who represents the local Thornton Dale and the Wolds division on the county council, said: “My belief is that the economic benefits are exaggerated and the relatively small amount of gas produced will make a tiny contribution to the nation’s energy requirements.”

Adam White, the chairman of AGHAST, a local group set up in the village of Thornton Dale to oppose the scheme, said: “This is a greenfield site which will industrialise a tranquil area if the scheme goes ahead.”

He claimed Moorland Energy had not evaluated alternative methods of processing the gas, and added: “We need to safeguard the landscape for the economic benefits the village gets from tourism. This project is not the only way to exploit gas reserves.”

Mr White said a similar plant had failed after only three years at nearby Pickering in the early 1970s.

The public inquiry is due to end on Tuesday next week before the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, Eric Pickles, makes a final decision next year.

The hearing continues.

email [email protected]