Farmer's turbine bid blocked by objectors

Sean Batty, of Harper Barn Farm, Bradshaw Lane, Bradshaw, Halifax, was refused permission to build a 24.5 metre structure on his land after 35 letters of objection.

At a meeting of Calderdale Council's planning committee, he challenged allegations that the 24.5-metre structure would be used as a commercial enterprise to sell energy to the National Grid.

He said it would produce a maximum of 50,000 kilowatt hours each year – only 70 per cent of the farm's requirements.

"In a nutshell we're doing our bit to reduce our impact on the environment because I do believe that the balance of nature rests on our actions." His agent said noise levels would reach a maximum of 44.6 decibels – equivalent to a "whisper".

Residents said that the turbine – which would stand on an 18-metre pole with 13-metre blades – would dominate the views from Bradshaw village.

They were also concerned that the rotor would be level with the windows of their homes.

One said: "Calderdale has sufficient remote and exposed areas not to have to permit wind turbines in residential areas. It's just too large and inappropriate for its location."

Residents said they would not object to a smaller turbine.

Calderdale councillor Barry Collins (Lab) said: "In my understanding, 18 metres is just under 80 feet – that's about twice the height of the Victoria Theatre in Halifax. I'm in favour of wind energy generation but it doesn't seem to me that this is appropriate near to houses."

Planning officers had recommended approval. Head of planning, Geoff Willerton, said that although it was in the green belt it was not inappropriate and would contribute towards renewable energy targets.

The application would normally have been determined by planning officers using delegated powers but was brought to the committee at the request of Coun Collins.