Free money: Record fines for rogue bankers who rigged the market

Five banks are to pay fines of more than £2 billion after the latest scandal to rock the industry saw traders referred to as the “Three Musketeers” and the “A-team” attempt to rig the £3 trillion-a-day foreign exchange market.
The five world's biggest banks are to pay fines totalling £2 billion after regulators lifted the lid on the latest scandal to rock the industry.The five world's biggest banks are to pay fines totalling £2 billion after regulators lifted the lid on the latest scandal to rock the industry.
The five world's biggest banks are to pay fines totalling £2 billion after regulators lifted the lid on the latest scandal to rock the industry.

Royal Bank of Scotland, HSBC, Citibank, JP Morgan Chase and UBS were handed penalties totalling a record £1.1 billion by Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and 1.5 billion US dollars (£927 million) by US authorities.

Investigators found traders from different firms formed groups under various code names in order to help them manipulate currency exchange rates that would profit the banks at the expense of clients.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Transcripts of conversations held in chat rooms and disclosed by the FCA today reveal how the traders referred to “free money” and not wanting other “numpty’s” in the market to know about information within their group.

The FCA said that the failure by the banks to control business practices undermined confidence in UK financial markets and put its integrity at risk, with 40% of forex trading taking place in London. However, the regulator said there was no suggestion that the practices had an impact on consumers.

As the findings cover a period between 2008 and October 2013, banks failed to act despite the previous scandal over the manipulation of the benchmark Libor interbank lending rate which resulted in billions of pounds of fines.

The Serious Fraud Office has launched a criminal investigation into the manipulation, while Royal Bank of Scotland said it has placed six individuals into a disciplinary process.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Bank of England was dragged into the scandal amid claims officials knew about the practices. A review today found while none were aware of “improper conduct”, one member of staff failed to raise the alarm about traders sharing information.

It said that its chief foreign exchange dealer, who was suspended in March, had been fired yesterday for “a failure to adhere to internal policies” but said it was “not at all related” to the forex probe.

FCA chief executive Martin Wheatley said: “Today’s record fines mark the gravity of the failings we found and firms need to take responsibility for putting it right. They must make sure their traders do not game the system to boost profits.”

The fines from the UK regulator dwarf its previous total penalties of £532 million for the Libor scandal and also set new records for its fines for individual banks, with the previous highest being £160 million.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Royal Bank of Scotland, which is 80% owned by the taxpayer, was fined a total of £399 million including £217 million by the FCA and 290 million US dollars (£182 million) by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

RBS said it has placed six individuals into a disciplinary process, three of whom are currently suspended, pending further investigation. It said it would make a statement about the probe by the end of the year.

Chairman Sir Philip Hampton said: “The RBS board fully accepts the criticisms within today’s announcements and condemns the actions of those employees responsible for this misconduct.”

Chief executive Ross McEwan added: “To say that I am angry about the misconduct would be an understatement.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“We had people working at this bank who did not know the difference between right and wrong, or worse, didn’t care about the distinction.”

He said that those responsible would have bonuses clawed back or face disciplinary procedures. The bank said six were undergoing a disciplinary process, with three suspended. A statement about the probe will follow by the end of the year.

The bank, which has analysed millions of documents, said it was reviewing the conduct of more than 50 current and former members of trading staff around the world as well as dozens of supervisors and senior management.

HSBC was fined £389 million including £216 million from the FCA and £173 million from the CFTC.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

However Barclays, the third British bank expected to be fined, said it was “in the interests of the company to seek a more general coordinated settlement” with more investigations from other authorities still to come.

It recently said it was setting aside £500 million to cover probes into the scandal.

Other bodies investigating the affair include Britain’s Serious Fraud Office and the US Department of Justice.

Swiss bank UBS was fined a total of £503 million including £234 million by the FCA, 290 million US dollars (£182 million) by the CFTC and 134 million Swiss francs (£87 million) by the Swiss regulator FINMA.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

America’s Citibank was hit with penalties of £420 million including just under £225.6 million from the FCA and 310 million US dollars (£194.6 million) from the CFTC.

JP Morgan Chase was fined £417 million including £222 million by the UK regulator and 310 million dollars (£195 million) from the CFTC.

Chancellor George Osborne said: “Today we take tough action to clean up corruption by a few so that we have a financial system that works for everyone.

“A number of traders have been suspended or fired, and the Serious Fraud Office are conducting criminal investigations. The banks that employed them face big fines - and I will ensure that these fines are used for the wider public good.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Fines collected by the FCA for the Libor scandal in the past have been passed on to charities including military causes.

The Bank of England’s review, carried out by Lord Grabiner, extracted and applied search terms to 1.8 million documents and reviewed nearly 66,000 documents and 87,000 telephone calls.

It found that no official was involved in any unlawful or improper behaviour in the forex market.

However one member of staff was aware that bank traders were sharing information about client orders for the purpose of “matching” - a practice that can increase the potential for improper conduct - but did not raise the alarm to superiors.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Andrea Leadsom, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “It’s completely disgusting.

“Every taxpayer will be completely horrified to see that throughout that period of the financial crisis where taxpayers were bailing out the financial system, there was still a group of foreign exchange traders, and other traders, who decided they would rig the system to suit their bonuses - and that is absolutely disgusting.

“I do not know if corruption is a strong enough word for it.”