Stop politicising the pandemic and start involving Parliament – Ken Clarke

This is the worst health crisis to
have hit this country and the worst depression – no, recession, so far – and economic crisis that has occurred in my lifetime.

The difficulty of dealing with it 
is that it is shrouded in total uncertainty.

All forecasts on all fronts are quite useless because the disease is new, its behaviour is unknown and therefore the range of scientific and medical opinion about the way in which it can be controlled and what is going to happen is not a unanimous science: it is immensely varied.

Quite unprecedented choices 
have to be made on the tensions 
between the life-saving prospects of doing one thing and the damaging economic consequences that step will have.

Everybody is going to second-guess every decision that Ministers come to as they go along.

As we are now in the days of public inquiries, with the wisdom of hindsight, everybody will be able to see what should have been done in the light of what we know has happened, and everybody will say how obvious it was that steps should have been taken.

Yes, the Government have made mistakes; every western government have made mistakes.

The mistake at the beginning was not being tough enough.

It is quite obvious that we should have gone into lockdown probably about three weeks before we did.

It is quite obvious that we should 
have quarantined flights in from 
places such as Spain and Italy almost instantly.

We should obviously have been more aware of the dangers to the residents of care homes and ended the practice of discharging patients from hospitals to care homes without testing before doing so.

But, if the Government had done those things at the beginning of March, they would have faced all the protests about civil liberties, excess infringements, controls and so on that we are hearing now.

We must not repeat that.

The policy succeeded after that because we had only about 60,000 excess deaths and, although we are as bad as almost any other country in the world, people have now got used to the small level of deaths – each of ​them tragic – and disaster we are having.

The demand now is: let us have more liberty and protect our freedom and let us not step things up.

The Government should subject themselves to more Parliamentary scrutiny of the next steps. I totally agree with all who have voiced that.

It would strengthen them and give them more authority. It would give them a better defence when they make an obvious mistake – and they will make more.

The position now is that they would also be strengthened by the support they would get.

The majority of the public support the measures that the Government are now taking.

The ‘rule of six’ is not particularly severe, while closing pubs at 10pm takes us back to the days of my teens, but is not actually a tremendous infringement of civil liberties.

Opinion polls show that the public would accept tougher measures 
from the Government and I think 
that, after proper debate and scrutiny, the majority in Parliament would allow most of them.

That would, however, save us 
from the occasional strange 
dilemmas and slips that we know have occurred.

The Government, the public and the nation will be held together better if we scrutinise more firmly, but not on the basis that we second guess every decision that any Minister makes and start politicising it in this extremely dangerous world.

Lord Clarke of Nottingham is a Tory peer and a former Chancellor. This is part of his maiden speech to the House of Lords.

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today.

Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app and receive exclusive members-only offers.

So, please - if you can - pay for our work. Just £5 per month is the starting point. If you think that which we are trying to achieve is worth more, you can pay us what you think we are worth. By doing so, you will be investing in something that is becoming increasingly rare. Independent journalism that cares less about right and left and more about right and wrong. Journalism you can trust.

Thank you

James Mitchinson