‘Herd immunity’ will not work, people need to adhere to Covid-19 measures - Yorkshire Post Letters

From: Mike Monkman, Harrogate.
How best to tackle the coronavirus is a subject of debate. Photo: Joe Giddens/PA WireHow best to tackle the coronavirus is a subject of debate. Photo: Joe Giddens/PA Wire
How best to tackle the coronavirus is a subject of debate. Photo: Joe Giddens/PA Wire

ONCE again, we hear from “experts” advocating that the virus should be allowed to run its course to achieve “herd immunity”.

Let the young live their lives and the elderly and vulnerable should shelter away, whilst the rest return to “normality”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

How normal will it be with a significant proportion of the population disengaged from society?

Restrictions are in place across the country to try to stop the spread of coronavirus. Photo: Andrew Milligan/PA WireRestrictions are in place across the country to try to stop the spread of coronavirus. Photo: Andrew Milligan/PA Wire
Restrictions are in place across the country to try to stop the spread of coronavirus. Photo: Andrew Milligan/PA Wire

At what age do they shield? The risk rises significantly after 50.

So all the bus drivers, train drivers, shop workers, taxi drivers over 50 should perhaps shield?

And the same for teachers and university lecturers, let the young ones teach the students.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Apprenticeships – no seniors passing on their skills, let the young ones do that.

Read More
The vulnerable need targeted protection from Covid-19, not local lockdowns - Yor...

These so-called experts no doubt live in large homes with huge gardens, highly paid and well able to protect themselves and their families from the effects of the virus “running its course”.

No consideration for the vast majority of the population, living in more cramped conditions, terraced housing, many young still living at home with older family members, unable to afford to buy or rent their own place.

How are their families to be protected?

How different the youth of the 1940s were, prepared to sacrifice their lives to protect their parents, grandparents and their way of life,

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

So unlike the all too many snowflakes of today, who want it all and care little about anything else.

This is not the only country affected and all other countries with similar infection levels are taking the same measures to slow the infection rate.

Did we have herd immunity from smallpox?

Do we have herd immunity from Ebola or HIV, or measles, mumps and rubella?

No, we have treatments and/or vaccines to prevent, or at least reduce the effects, that these infections have.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It is not the measures the Government is taking that is the problem.

It is the fact that all too many are failing to adhere to them.

You only have to look to Singapore, South Korea and, yes, China.

Failure to follow the rules is not tolerated and they are strictly enforced, allowing their economies to remain open and business to function near normal.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today. Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app and receive exclusive members-only offers. Click here to subscribe.