Pest infestations, broken furniture and overcrowding - These are the housing problems experienced by some UK migrants

Two surveys run from Yorkshire have highlighted some of the housing experiences of migrants living in the UK - and what can be done to improve them. Laura Reid reports.

New research has shed light on the housing conditions experienced by migrants. Pictures: Chris ODonovan via The Children's Society.
New research has shed light on the housing conditions experienced by migrants. Pictures: Chris ODonovan via The Children's Society.

“I was crippled with fear,” writes a young man, known only under the pseudonym of Isaac. “When I was in the house, I spent most of my time in my bedroom. It was a very hard time.”

Isaac is among 158 people who have recently contributed to a survey highlighting the housing experiences of migrants in the UK. Whilst seeking asylum, he recalls living in a "rat-infested" area in Bradford and says he was in fear of being attacked by one of his housemates.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

Pest infestations, broken furniture, overcrowding and challenges with housemates were all among issues reported in the survey, carried out by academics at Leeds Beckett University last month. Participants were asked about their housing circumstances (of any form, Government-provided or otherwise) when they first came to the UK and three in five of those who responded said they had experienced problems.

Surveys into housing experiences have been carried out by Leeds Beckett University and ST4R. Pictures: Chris ODonovan via The Children's Society.

Most common in relation to the accommodation itself were issues accessing the internet, poor heating and dirtiness. Just over a third said they did not feel safe in the area they lived in and of those living with strangers, half said they felt they could not be themselves around their housemates and 20 per cent claimed they were not treated fairly by them.

The responses have informed a comic strip entitled Home Truths and designed by visual storyteller Karrie Fransman. It is hoped the resource will shine a light on the “inadequate” living arrangements that many migrants face.

Comments from Isaac are included in the comic. The now 26-year-old left Uganda in 2010 to come to the UK as an international student and study for his A-Levels. When he first arrived in the country, he was living in London with a British family under a homestay arrangement.

Read More

Read More
Young refugee finds sanctuary with foster carers in Leeds after fleeing Iran and...

Isaac then moved to Bradford to study at university, later enrolling to complete a PhD after graduation. But when he left that two years later and claimed asylum, his housing struggles began. Whilst the Government provides accommodation to asylum seekers who do not have any other way of supporting themselves, housing is offered on a ‘no choice’ basis, meaning people cannot select where they live unless in exceptional circumstances.

Isaac says the Home Office planned for him to move away from his support network in Bradford, where he had then lived for nearly six years. “Leaving would have made it extremely difficult to receive the essential support from friends that I needed for my asylum claim to be successful,” he reflects. “I was very worried about the financial, social and emotional consequences of such an action and the inability to prepare my case effectively.”

After several petitions, Isaac says he was able to stay in Bradford and allocated a room in a house. But his relief was shortlived. “It was in a very unsafe area and very rough and rat-infested. I was living with three other asylum seekers who had been waiting for a response on their asylum claim for many years. Unfortunately, one of them became a heroin and crack addict and would invite friends over regularly to partake in taking [drugs]. It quickly became clear that I wouldn’t be able to safely and peacefully remain there.

“I was in a constant state of fear...One of my housemates, for fear of being reported to the police, would often be paranoid and bang on my room door, threatening to physically attack me. I was afraid of being attacked and having my property stolen.”

Isaac raised concerns with LGBT migrant charity Micro Rainbow and was moved to a safe house. The organisation is one of those listed in the Home Truths comic strip and researcher Dr Glen Jankowski, senior lecturer in the Leeds School of Social Sciences at Leeds Beckett, hopes the study findings will encourage people to donate to organisations that offer support to migrants or back campaigns that aim to improve conditions.

“Housing is a very basic necessity and if you don’t have that, then you’re not able to build your life in other ways,” Dr Jankowski says. “We know migrants contribute enormously to our culture and our economy but we’re not facilitating that if we aren’t providing even basic accommodation.”

The Leeds Beckett research is not the only work to be done in the field. The Children’s Society has also published a report showing the results of a survey that looked at young refugee and asylum seekers’ experiences in the UK. The survey was designed by Stand Together 4 Refugees (ST4R) in Leeds, a group of young refugees and asylum seekers themselves, aged 15 to 23.

A total of 61 young people responded, having been asked about any problems they’d experienced, what had helped and what they think needs to change to make things better for young refugees and asylum seekers. A number of themes came out of the research, which has also been captured in a booklet created by members of ST4R.

One of those was living circumstances, with two fifths of respondents saying they had experienced a problem with housing (of any form, Government-provided or otherwise) or having nowhere to live.

Several described basic amenities in their National Asylum Support Service accommodation as being in disrepair, with some saying they had been without electricity, heating or hot water. People also reported problems with housing after they were granted refugee status, saying they struggled to work out how to find accommodation, pay bills and open bank accounts.

ST4R member Winta, who requested to be referred to only by her first name, worked on the housing page of the booklet, which claims unaccompanied youngsters need more help, including with skills to enable them to live independently.

Winta, now 19, arrived in the country from Eritrea in 2017 and was housed with a foster family. They have supported her through the asylum process, helped her to learn English and have also been preparing her for her own house by showing her the ropes with paying bills, managing money, shopping and cooking. “They have helped me to adjust to a new life over here,” she says. “Without foster care, it would be very hard. It’s a new country with a new language.”

Winta, who lives in Leeds, says friends who have been living in independent accommodation have often felt “scared”. “Because they don’t know how to do things like paying bills, cooking, cleaning, going online to sort things out like banking. It’s very hard”, she elaborates. “It’s a sad feeling to think of them like that. They don’t know how to do things and then they feel stressed and sad.”

The next steps for ST4R will be to look at ways it can work to improve housing for other young people. “Our new research has shown many young refugee and migrant children are having to live in accommodation that is woefully inadequate,” says Amra Bibi, service manager at The Children’s Society. “It is vital that accommodation issues are addressed and these vulnerable young people are given a warm and safe environment, with Wi-Fi access, to call home.”

A spokesperson for the Home Office said: “Asylum seekers who would otherwise be destitute receive free, fully furnished accommodation, with their essential living needs whilst their claims are being assessed. When issues do occur in our accommodation, we work swiftly to ensure they are resolved as soon as possible.”

In response to the Leeds Beckett University survey, the department added: “We do not accept the claims contained within this report, which appears to be based upon a statistically small sample size, including some that appear to reside in private, rented accommodation.”

Visit glenjankowski.wordpress.com to see the Leeds Beckett research and for the ST4R study, visit www.childrenssociety.org.uk

For more stories from the YP Magazine and The Yorkshire Post features team, visit our Facebook page.

Editor’s note: first and foremost - and rarely have I written down these words with more sincerity - I hope this finds you well.

Almost certainly you are here because you value the quality and the integrity of the journalism produced by The Yorkshire Post’s journalists - almost all of which live alongside you in Yorkshire, spending the wages they earn with Yorkshire businesses - who last year took this title to the industry watchdog’s Most Trusted Newspaper in Britain accolade.

And that is why I must make an urgent request of you: as advertising revenue declines, your support becomes evermore crucial to the maintenance of the journalistic standards expected of The Yorkshire Post. If you can, safely, please buy a paper or take up a subscription. We want to continue to make you proud of Yorkshire’s National Newspaper but we are going to need your help.

Postal subscription copies can be ordered by calling 0330 4030066 or by emailing [email protected]. Vouchers, to be exchanged at retail sales outlets - our newsagents need you, too - can be subscribed to by contacting subscriptions on 0330 1235950 or by visiting www.localsubsplus.co.uk where you should select The Yorkshire Post from the list of titles available.

If you want to help right now, download our tablet app from the App / Play Stores. Every contribution you make helps to provide this county with the best regional journalism in the country.

Sincerely. Thank you.

James Mitchinson