BBC accused of 'trivialising' defence debate in interview with Labour's Gardiner

Shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner has accused the BBC of "trivialising the debate" on defence ahead of a speech where Jeremy Corbyn will attempt to shake off his pacifist image.
Shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner, who has accused the BBC of "trivialising the debate" on defence.Shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner, who has accused the BBC of "trivialising the debate" on defence.
Shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner, who has accused the BBC of "trivialising the debate" on defence.

In a fraught interview, Mr Gardiner condemned presenter Nick Robinson for reading out The Sun's headline on the Labour leaked manifesto - Crash, Bang, Wallies - which he said was "beneath" him.

He said: "This is the Today programme and people expect a standard of debate that is higher than 'Crash, Bang, Wallop'."

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mr Robinson interjected: "They expect us to read out newspaper headlines like we do every morning and have done for many, many years without backing them, endorsing them or criticising them."

The front page of The Sun.The front page of The Sun.
The front page of The Sun.

Mr Gardiner replied: "And they expect you to actually exercise a degree of choice and discretion."

The exchange came as Mr Corbyn was due to use a speech to a leading international affairs think tank to cast off his image as a pacifist unwilling to take military action while denouncing Theresa May's closeness to Donald Trump's administration.

Mr Gardiner, speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, said he would welcome a leader who did not "jump to the tune" of the United States over military action.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

He said: "I'm really pleased that we could have a prime minister who is reluctant and thinks carefully before putting our servicemen and women in harm's ways, who won't simply, you know, jump to the tune the moment that a US president snaps their fingers and says come and join me in a bombing raid."

The front page of The Sun.The front page of The Sun.
The front page of The Sun.

Pressed on when Mr Corbyn would use military action, Mr Gardiner became agitated, saying: "You ask a question and then you want to answer it."

He went on: "He (Jeremy Corbyn) is absolutely committed to the security of this country. If this country were under military threat, if this country were at risk of being attacked by another nation, of course as prime minister and of course a Labour cabinet would be wanting to ensure our security."

Mr Gardiner rejected "throwaway" remarks made by Mr Corbyn, where he could not think of examples when he would intervene with military action.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

He said: "Picking up sort of points like that I do think you are trivialising the debate, let's focus on the really important stuff which is the need for conflict prevention in this world, the need for conflict resolution in this world, the role that diplomacy has to play in reducing the tensions that we see."

Mr Gardiner told the programme "no one has a stronger record" on speaking out against genocide, human rights abuse and war crimes than the Labour leader.

After the interview Mr Robinson tweeted: "Wonder if Barry Gardiner had three Shredded Wheat this morning?"