Timeline: How Bradford MP triggered anti-Semitism crisis that engulfed Labour

Naz Shah's suspension from the Labour Party came at the end of a fast-moving sequence of events triggered by the revelation of social media posts from years ago.
Speaker John Bercow said her words had been "noted by the House" after Labour MP Naz Shah tells the House of Commons in London that she "wholeheartedly apologises" for words she used in a Facebook post about Israel.Speaker John Bercow said her words had been "noted by the House" after Labour MP Naz Shah tells the House of Commons in London that she "wholeheartedly apologises" for words she used in a Facebook post about Israel.
Speaker John Bercow said her words had been "noted by the House" after Labour MP Naz Shah tells the House of Commons in London that she "wholeheartedly apologises" for words she used in a Facebook post about Israel.

But it has also left party leader Jeremy Corbyn facing accusations that he acted too slowly.

Here is the timeline of how events unfolded:

Suspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit LabourSuspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit Labour
Suspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit Labour
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

• August 2014 - Ms Shah shares an image on Facebook of the outline of Israel superimposed on a map of the USA, under the heading “Solution for Israel-Palestine Conflict - Relocate Israel into United States”. She adds the comment “problem solved”, and said she would pass on the suggestion to David Cameron and Barack Obama.

• May 2015 - Ms Shah is elected Labour MP for Bradford West, defeating Respect’s George Galloway.

• Monday April 25 - The Guido Fawkes website approaches Ms Shah to ask her about the Facebook post. The site later reports that she confirmed it was genuine and said she wanted to issue an apology and an explanation of how her views had changed.

Suspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit LabourSuspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit Labour
Suspended Labour MP Naz Shah, as the the party's leadership has faced a backlash over the latest anti-Semitism row to hit Labour

• Tuesday April 26, 7.50am - Details of the Facebook post are revealed by the Guido Fawkes website.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

10.45am - Labour issues a statement from Ms Shah saying that the post “does not reflect my views and I apologise for any offence it has caused.”

12.45pm - Campaign Against Anti-Semitism says apology is not enough and warns that it will be unable to take the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee seriously if Ms Shah remains a member.

1pm - Labour issues a further statement from Ms Shah, saying she “unreservedly” apologises for the hurt caused by her comments and has stepped down as an aide to shadow chancellor John McDonnell.

3.30pm - A further Facebook post from September 2014 emerges, in which Ms Shah shared Martin Luther King’s quote “Never Forget that Everything Hitler did in Germany was Legal” along with the comment “#Apartheid Israel”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

• Wednesday April 27, morning - Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn meets Ms Shah.

11am - A Twitter message emerges, sent by Ms Shah in July 2014, in which she urged supporters of the Palestinians to vote in an online poll on Israeli military action, claiming that “the Jews are rallying” to skew the result.

11.35am - Mr Corbyn issues a statement to say that he has told Ms Shah her actions were “offensive and unacceptable” and affirms Labour’s “implacable” opposition to anti-semitism.

11.45am - Minutes before Prime Minister’s Questions in the House of Commons, Labour shadow cabinet member Lisa Nandy tells BBC2’s Daily Politics she has spoken to the leader’s office and told them the party should suspend “anybody who makes anti-semitic remarks” without exception.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

11.55am - Jewish News publishes an article from Ms Shah apologising to the Jewish community.

12.10pm - As Mr Corbyn attempts to question the Prime Minister about academy schools, David Cameron tells him: “Perhaps if you could deal with the anti-Semites in your own party, we’d be prepared to listen to you more.” The PM says it is “extraordinary” that she still has the Labour whip.

2.35pm - Ms Shah uses a point of order in the House of Commons to acknowledge that she has made a “mistake” and offer a “wholehearted” apology.

4.10pm - Labour announces that, by “mutual agreement” with Mr Corbyn, Ms Shah has been suspended by the party’s general secretary and an investigation launched into her comments.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

5pm - Former major Labour donor David Abrahams announces he is withdrawing support from the party over anti-semitism.

10.45pm - Labour peer Lord Levy tells BBC2s Newsnight that Mr Corbyn “dithered” and took too long to act over Ms Shah. Crossbench peer Rabbi Baroness Neuberger tells the programme Labour has “a problem with anti-semitism”.

Thursday, April 28, 8.45am - Labour MP Rupa Huq defends Ms Shah on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, saying her post was the result of a “silly moment”.

10am - Former London mayor Ken Livingstone denies there is anti-semitism in the Labour Party in an interview on BBC Radio London in which he says that Hitler was a Zionist.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

10.45am - Labour’s candidate for London mayor Sadiq Khan denounces Mr Livingstone’s comment as “appalling and inexcusable” and calls for his removal from the party.

• Thursday April 28, 1.30pm - Ken Livingstone suspended by Labour for “bringing the party into disrepute”.