Yorkshire medic hits out at 'shameful' levels of health spending as UK lags behind other leading nations

0
Have your say

The UK lags behind nine other high-income countries when it comes to health service spending, outcomes and how much time doctors spend with patients, research has suggested.

The study, published in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), said the quality of NHS care appears to be "slipping", with Britons faring worse than their counterparts abroad. A senior Yorkshire medic said the results backed up what the region's doctors had been saying for years.

UK spending on health lags behind other rich nations, research suggests

UK spending on health lags behind other rich nations, research suggests

The claims came as Labour and the Tories were involved in a furious clash over claims the Conservatives would put the NHS "up for sale" in a post-Brexit trade deal with the US.

Jeremy Corbyn dramatically produced what he said were 451 pages of "uncensored" government documents which, he said, showed the NHS would be "on the table" in talks with the Trump administration.

Read more: Senior Yorkshire backbencher Richard Burgon says Labour is 'sorry' for hurt to Jewish community over anti-Semitism

Read more: After changing the rules on political advertising, Google is setting out its own vision for democracy

Experts from the London School of Economics and Harvard School of Public Health compared the UK with nine comparable high-income countries: Australia, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland and the US.

They used data, including from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), to look at seven key areas of health.

The findings showed the UK had the lowest healthcare expenditure per person at £2,978, compared with an average of £4,438 in the other countries.

Dr Brian McGregor, Leeds GP and Yorkshire regional council chair for the British Medical Association, said: “It’s shameful that Britain is lagging behind its overseas counterparts, but sadly this reflects what doctors in Yorkshire and across the country have been saying for some time.

“Chronic underinvestment has led to long waits and staff shortages in our GP practices and hospitals, and it means that patients are too often not getting the care they deserve.

“This report underlines the need for a significant boost to health spending if we are to ensure the NHS meets present needs and put it on a solid footing for the future.”

The findings showed the UK had the lowest healthcare expenditure per person of the 10 featured in the study at £2,978, compared with an average of £4,438 in the other countries.

Overall, the UK spent approximately 8.7% of GDP on health in 2017, compared with the average of 11.5%.

Even when social care was included, the UK spent less overall than its counterparts, the study found.

When it comes to doctors, the UK had fewer, at 2.8 per 1,000 people in 2017, compared with an average of 3.5, and the number is falling.

The number of practising nurses in the UK in 2017 was also "considerably lower" at 7.8 per 1,000 people, compared with an average of 11.4 in the other countries.

The report found patients had slightly fewer consultations with a doctor, and GPs in the UK reported spending the least amount of time with patients.

None said they spent 25 or more minutes with a patient, compared with an average of 15% in other countries, while 8% spent 15 to 25 minutes (45% in other countries), and 92% spent less than 15 minutes (38% in other countries).

While waiting times for GP appointments were only slightly longer in the UK, 19% of patients waited two months or more to see a specialist, compared with a 12% average in other countries.

The study also found the UK had fewer hospital beds, at 2.5 per 1,000 people, compared with four per 1,000 in other countries.

The UK had the lowest survival rates for breast and colon cancer, and the third highest number of preventable deaths.

The country was also behind on the proportion of patients suffering sepsis after abdominal surgery, and death within 30 days following a heart attack, or three days after a stroke.

However, there were fewer healthcare-associated infections in the UK, fewer people suffered a blood clot after surgery and more over-65s had a flu jab.

There were also more women undergoing breast and cervical screening, although rates in the UK are declining at a faster rate.

Smoking rates in 2017 were far lower in the UK, but alcohol consumption was about average and rates of obesity were higher.

The authors said: "Our study suggests that the NHS should look towards improving staffing ratios, long-term care provision, and social spending, which are lower than comparator countries and have been declining in recent years.

"Despite already low levels of labour, the UK is making do with fewer doctors and nurses, a challenge that is likely to be exacerbated in the context of Brexit.

"Although access to care compared favourably to other countries, utilisation was lower than average and quality seems to be slipping. Health service outcomes, as well as heath status, are sub-optimal."

The study said the UK "will almost certainly need to spend more on healthcare staffing, long-term care, and other social services" in the future.

The Conservatives have promised an NHS budget rise of 3.4% a year on average, so that by 2023/24, £149 billion will be spent.

Labour has said it will spend more - £6 billion extra a year by 2023/24, which the Lib Dems have pledged to match.

Mark Dayan, policy analyst at the Nuffield Trust, said: "Our work last year with the Institute for Fiscal Studies, King's Fund and Health Foundation showed the UK lags behind on many areas of cancer and in overall avoidable deaths for killer diseases.

"But the NHS does appear relatively efficient, and actually has perfectly normal waiting times despite the complaints we so often hear.

"This report is right to point to low levels of key staff as an underlying concern.

"Another standing problem is the low level of equipment, with MRI and CT scanner levels the lowest among comparable countries."