Terrified and undiscovered, girl, 4, survives French Alps massacre

Police stand outside the home of Saad al-Hilli in Claygate, Surrey. Below: Eric Maillaud, the Prosecutor of Annecy.
Police stand outside the home of Saad al-Hilli in Claygate, Surrey. Below: Eric Maillaud, the Prosecutor of Annecy.
Have your say

THREE of the four people shot dead when a gunman opened fire on a British family in the French Alps were hit in the middle of the head, it was revealed today.

Public prosecutor Eric Maillaud described the attack, which left the driver, two women and a passing cyclist dead, as an act of “gross savagery”.

Eric Maillaud, the Prosecutor of Annecy, holds a press conference in the town in the Haute-Savoie region of south-eastern France.

Eric Maillaud, the Prosecutor of Annecy, holds a press conference in the town in the Haute-Savoie region of south-eastern France.

A four-year-old girl, named locally as Zeena al-Hilli, was found alive underneath the bodies of her family around eight hours after the massacre.

And a seven-year-old girl, thought to be her sister Zainab, was found violently beaten and is in a coma, fighting for her life.

Zeena lay undiscovered as police waited for forensic experts to arrive at the scene from Paris. She was found “terrorised, motionless, in the midst of the bodies” after fellow campers at a nearby site told officers the family had two children, Mr Maillaud said.

He defended the delay in finding her as he revealed she was receiving psychiatric treatment.

Gendarmes block access to a killing site near Chevaline, French Alps

Gendarmes block access to a killing site near Chevaline, French Alps

A man and two women - believed to be the girls’ mother Iqbal, father Saad and an older relative - were in the British-registered BMW, which was riddled with bullets.

Mr al-Hilli, from Claygate, near Esher in Surrey, was behind the wheel at the time of the attack.

Mr Maillaud revealed that he was 50 years old, was originally from Iraq and held British citizenship.

A British cyclist, a former member of the RAF, who stumbled upon the shocking scene and spotted the seven-year-old lying in the road, placed her in the recovery position.

Speaking at a press conference today he was praised by Mr Maillaud, who said the four-year-old was in a traumatised condition.

“Can you imagine the state of the young girl, four years old, has spent eight hours under a body that was not moving...”

Police said the motive for the attack remained a mystery but revealed there were signs of a vehicle braking at the scene.

Mr Maillaud also revealed that Swedish and Iraqi passports had been recovered along with the driver’s British passport.

Mr Maillaud said the British cyclist was overtaken earlier by the French bicycle-rider found shot at the scene.

He said the British man told them he came across the “powerful” BMW estate with the engine still running.

“He also saw coming towards the car a young girl who collapsed before him,” he said.

“He quickly came to her and put her in a side position and called the police and ambulance service and everyone came to the scene.”

He said the girl had been repeatedly hit “extremely violently”.

The British cyclist then went the vehicle and found the French victim by its side. He broke a window and turned the car engine off and found the other three bodies in the car.

“We are talking about particularly horrific and alarming deaths,” he added.

The media gathered outside Mr al-Hilli’s home in Claygate, Surrey this afternoon.

Two plain-clothed police officers stood outside the two-storey detached house before three uniformed officers arrived.

Two of the officers entered a gate at the side of the property.

Neighbour Jason Kosbab, who said he did not know Mr al-Hilli’s family, said: “Claygate is a very close knit village. This is certainly going to bring everybody together.”

Mr al-Hilli and his family had been holidaying in a caravan at the Le Solitaire du Lac campsite in nearby Saint-Jorioz.

Their BMW was discovered surrounded by spent bullet cartridges in a car park near footpaths on the outskirts of a forest near Lake Annecy, a picturesque region popular with tourists.

The cyclist who reported the shooting is thought to be a retired man who was familiar with the area and was a regular visitor.

Speaking earlier Mr Maillaud described the scene as being like something from a film and said 15 cartridges were found around the BMW and a “very large number” of shots had been fired.

The firearm used is believed to be an automatic pistol.

The two dead women were found in the back seat of the car along with a number of bags.

The seven-year-old was taken to the nearby Grenoble University Hospital where her condition had stabilised following emergency surgery.

“We don’t know when we will be able to question her and I would imagine she is in a state of shock,” Mr Maillaud said.

Investigators said no weapon had been found and no arrests had been made.

It was also unclear if the shootings were carried out by one killer or a number of people.

Mr Maillaud said: “We don’t know who could have done this. We have no idea.”

One theory is that shots could have been fired during a bungled armed robbery, with the dead cyclist - named as Sylvain Mollier - being a witness to the crime.

He worked for a firm based some miles away and was identified after his wife became worried when he did not return from a bike ride.

She went to a local police station with a photograph of her husband and officers established he was the fourth victim.

Mr Maillaud said he found himself in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Investigators were today inspecting a caravan used by the family at the campsite.

One woman said: “I saw the two women yesterday with the two little girls collecting apples.

“Everything seemed normal, but I didn’t know them. It was the first year that they had been seen here. It is terrible. The atmosphere is heavy, nobody is speaking.”

The Foreign Office said the British Embassy’s deputy head of mission in France was at the scene of the shooting.

“She is liaising with the local authorities and police to get more information,” a spokesman said.

Foreign Secretary William Hague tweeted: “Terrible, tragic shooting in France.

“British Embassy team on the scene. Our thoughts are with the young girls who survived and the family.”

Talking about the delay in finding the four-year-old girl, Mr Maillaud said at the news conference that it was important to the investigators to ensure that the inquiry was undertaken as well as possible.

“Things have to be done with method, otherwise we can’t find the people responsible for the crime,” he said.

“At the time of the intervention of the emergency services, nothing allowed us to think that there was somebody else in the car. There was no way of knowing.”

It was a neighbour at the camp site who said to investigators that there were two children - there was only one child seat in the car, Mr Maillaud said.

“They discovered this girl, totally immobilised, she was buried under the front passenger seat, among big bags, she was not visible.”

Physically, now, she was very well, he said.

“She was happy to be in the hands of the investigators who got her out of the car.”

He said three of the four who died were hit by a gunshot right in the middle of the head - the two men, and the older woman. Post mortem examinations will be carried out tomorrow afternoon in Grenoble.

Mr Maillaud praised the actions of the former member of the RAF.

“He had a strong command of his nerves. We must welcome his action and congratulate him,” he said.

The older woman had a Swedish passport, and investigators had also discovered an Iraqi passport.

He dismissed suggestions that the gunshots showed “professionalism”, saying: “I do not want to invent or imagine, my role is to discover what happened. Yes, we are talking about an act of gross savagery.”

He said there were traces of braking on the ground, but there was no impact to the body of the car, only to the windows and to the people.

Jack Saltman, whose house backs on to the family home in Claygate, said Mr al-Hilli had said something to him before he went on holiday that he would be informing the police about.

Speaking to Sam Walker on the Richard Bacon Show on Radio 5 Live, he said: “I know one little thing which I am not prepared to speak (about) at the moment. I will tell the police about it.

“It was something Saad said to me before he went but at this stage I do not feel I can disclose that but I will tell the police exactly what he told me before he left.”

He described his neighbour as “a massively helpful man, a wonderful engineer” who helped him repair household machinery when it broke down.

He said Mr al-Hilli had said they were going to France for around a week-and-a-half to try to “get a bit of extra holiday in before the kids went back to school”.

Mrs al-Hilli, he said, was a trainee dentist working at a practice locally.

“His two daughters were absolutely gorgeous, they were beautiful little girls,” he added.

“Zainab, the elder girl, highly articulate, highly intelligent girl. The little girl was vivacious, full of life, a really bubbly little girl.

“They used to play together in the back garden and when I was working in the garden they would always come over and have a chat.”

A spokeswoman for the foreign ministry in Sweden said: “We do see the French information as reliable but we are still waiting for the formal identification before we can confirm her identity.

“We do consider the French information reliable. Our embassy in Paris are following this case, they are in close contact with the French authorities.”