Traffic fears over plan for busy retail site

In December 2006 consent was granted for a new store at a retail park off Archer Drive, close to the existing Fitness First gym and a McDonald's restaurant.

A condition was put on that planning permission which would only allow the shop to sell heavy goods such as DIY equipment, furniture, carpets and electrical goods. The foundations of the building have already been put in, although the owner is unable to find a retailer to take over the unit.

They have now applied to Sheffield Council to amend the application so that any non-food retailer can move in. Neighbours have objected to the application, saying that opening another popular business would create increased congestion.

Residents are also fighting planning applications submitted by the neighbouring Sainsbury and Tesco supermarkets to extend both stores, which they say would also increase traffic and have an effect on air quality.

The Carter Knowle and Millhouses Community Group says that altering the planning consent will "turn the neighbourhood into a retail park".

Coun Sylvia Dunkley added: "The sale of more general retail goods, as opposed to bulky goods, will create even more traffic congestion, air pollution and pressure on local shops at Millhouses and Woodseats."

Planning officers, however, have recommended that the application should be granted when it is considered by councillors today. They say: "There will be an estimated increase of 60 vehicles daily, based on a comparison between bulky goods retailers and large non-food retailers, with an overall generation of 400 vehicles per day.

"The car parking, servicing provision and highway network is capable of accommodating this negligible increase in overall traffic activity.

"Overall, the unrestricted sale of comparison goods from the approved bulky goods retail unit is considered acceptable."