Presenter defends ‘rape isn’t always rape’ claims in book

Broadcaster Nick Ross was forced to defend himself yesterday over controversial remarks suggesting “rape isn’t always rape”.

The former Crimewatch presenter made the comments in his new book, serialised in the Mail on Sunday, in which he claimed half of all women who have had penetrative sex unwillingly do not think they were raped.

The comments, which have been criticised by some anti-rape campaigners, follow an outcry in 2011 when Ken Clarke, the then-Justice Secretary, faced calls to resign for using the words “serious rape”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

In a statement, Mr Ross, 65, insisted the book was “serious, carefully researched and evidence-based” and described rape as “one of the most defiling crimes”.

He said: “Far from attacking victims the chapter explores why so few victims report rape, why so few prosecutions take place, and whether criminal courts are the best way of helping to deal with the appalling suffering caused by sex attacks,” he said.

In his book, Crime, Mr Ross said it had become “sacrilege to suggest that there can be any gradation: rape is rape”.

“The real experts, the victims, know otherwise,” he wrote.

“Half of all women who have had penetrative sex unwillingly do not think they were raped, and this proportion rises strongly when the assault involves a boyfriend, or if the woman is drunk or high on drugs: they went too far, it wasn’t forcible, they didn’t make themselves clear...

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“For them, rape isn’t always rape and however upsetting, they feel is a long way removed from being systematically violated or snatched off the street.”

Mr Ross said the paper had chosen to focus on a single chapter which “touches on the highly emotive issue of rape”.

He admitted the edited version was fair but claimed his views were not as thoroughly explained as in the full text of the book.

In his statement, Mr Ross said: “For the record, lest it needs saying, and, as I make clear in the published extracts, anyone who suffers such a violating crime should be the centre of our concerns. As I write in the book, rape is one of the most defiling crimes and there is never excuse or justification for it.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mr Ross added: “I sincerely believe the book raises powerful and important challenges to conventional thinking about crime – and those who have read the book have praised it. There may – and I’m sure will be – reasoned arguments against some of the things I say.

“But it is nothing like as simplistic, let alone objectionable, as some people would have you believe. This is a false storm.”

Related topics: