Tom Kohler-Cadmore top scored for the visitors with an innings of 52 guiding them to a competitive total of 146-6 from their 20 overs, while Nathan Rimmington claimed figures of 3-16 to keep the Vikings in check.
After Yorkshire were inserted, Adam Lyth sliced Scott Steel to Brydon Carse, before Matty Potts removed David Willey for two with a catch off his own bowling.
Kohler-Cadmore tried to get the Vikings moving, blasting a huge six into the crowd off Liam Trevaskis. However, Yorkshire lost their third wicket of the powerplay when Jonny Tattersall, failed to connect with his drive off Rimmington as Graham Clark claimed the catch.
Jack Leaning and Kohler-Cadmore built an impressive stand for the fourth wicket, Kohler-Cadmore reaching his half-century from 40 deliveries, including two boundaries and a six. Rimmington’s return to the attack was crucial, forcing the mistake from Kohler-Cadmore, who skied his pull shot, allowing to Clark take his second catch.
Rimmington notched his third wicket when Leaning picked out Harry Adair at backward point. Will Fraine picked out D’Arcy Short on the rope before Tim Bresnan finished with a six.
Short and Steel saw the home side score 64 from the opening six overs, but Shutt sparked the Vikings into life. He turned one through Short’s gate to bowl the Aussie for 29. Adair made four before he fell to Shutt, picking out Lyth in the deep, putting the pressure on the hosts.
Steel and Peter Handscomb nudged Durham over the 100-run mark, but Shutt removed the former, who feathered an edge through to Tattersall behind the stumps. The off-spinner put the clamps on, dismissing Gareth Harte and then Handscomb in the space of three deliveries, to claim 5-11, his first five-wicket haul in T20 cricket.
For the second time in two matches, Durham failed to handle the pressure of the chase as Lyth took the wickets of Ben Raine, Trevaskis and Clark before a run-out between Potts and Rimmington secured a huge win for the Vikings.
Afterwards, Shutt said he was surprised at how successful he had proved with the ball.5-11
“I can’t believe what’s happened out there,” he said. “There was a little bit in the pitch for me. Sometimes in T20 cricket it just goes for you and sometimes it’s your night. I’m really really pleased. There was a little grip in the first innings, so we knew there was a bit in the pitch. All four of the spinners that bowled tonight bowled well.
“I’ve not been involved in a game like that. It’s still surreal.
“You can’t get carried away with T20 there are going to be a lot of highs and lows. You’ve got to keep yourself consistent because you’re going to have ups and downs so you’ve got to ride it.”
Kohler-Cadmore added: “Jack [Shutt] bowled incredibly. In the powerplay they had a great start, but then Jack and Keshan Maharaj brought us back into the game.
“We got gifted a couple of wickets towards the end. The way he bowled for such a young lad in just his fourth game to come out and produce figures like that is really special.
“The ball Jack bowled to dismiss Short was special. To beat a player of his quality with a delivery like that was great.
“He’s not come on and got lucky wickets that can happen in T20 cricket, he’s got genuine wickets which is credit to how well he bowled tonight.”