Repentant Clark gets long ban but Judge deems him ‘no thug’

His Honour Judge Jeff Blackett, though, took a dim view of the former Leeds Carnegie forward’s actions during the LV= Cup final defeat against Leicester two weeks ago when he hyperextended Tigers hooker Rob Hawkins’s arm.

It left Hawkins with a broken elbow and requiring surgery, sidelining him for the rest of the season.

Clark’s suspension of 32 weeks is among the longest handed out to a senior English player during rugby union’s 16-and-a-half-year professional era.

In the hearing’s written judgment, which was released yesterday by the Rugby Football Union, Clark said he played the rest of the final “in a fog” after realising what he had done.

Clark said: “I realised what I had done – I put my hand to my mouth.

“I knew I was responsible, and played rest of game in a fog. After the game I was approached by their (Leicester’s) coach who made it clear what he thought. For me, the result of the game was insignificant.

“I am physical and aggressive, but always play within the laws of the game. It has been hard to deal with how others now think of me as a player.” Clark sought out Hawkins after the final to apologise, but that was not well-received, and he now intends writing a letter of apology.

In his judgment, RFU disciplinary officer Blackett said: “The offending was intentional.

“The player clearly intended to pull Hawkins’s arm backwards after the whistle had been blown so that the ball became available and his side could play the ball quickly.

“I accept that he did not intend to harm Hawkins or cause him injury. I come to that conclusion because the player is not known as one who commits foul play, and by the way he presented and expressed himself at the hearing.

“He is not a thug and presented as a genuine young man who was prepared to, and accepted, responsibility for his actions and their consequences.

“I assessed that this offence was high on the scale of seriousness, not least because the player intentionally bent a vulnerable opponent’s arm backwards causing a very severe injury, and he did so after the referee had blown his whistle to stop play.

“In assessing it as serious, I would like to stress that I accept that the player is not malicious and did not intend to cause serious injury.”

In deciding the length of suspension, Blackett said there were no precedents to assist him.

“Had there been any evidence that the player intended to hurt an opponent (even if he did not mean to injure him) the appropriate entry point would have been in the order of five years’ suspension,” Blackett added.

“That is not the case here, so the entry point can be considerably lower. The player must be suspended for a good deal longer than Hawkins is absent from the game to reflect the seriousness of the offending.”

Clark was named in the England elite player squad in January, although he did not feature in any of the country’s Six Nations’ games.

Northampton, who suspended Clark indefinitely following his citing, say they are “bound to consider the merits of an appeal”. Saints have until midday next Tuesday to lodge any protest.