Christian rights bid reaches end of line in Europe
Shirley Chaplin, Gary McFarlane and Lillian Ladele saw their discrimination claims rejected by the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg earlier this year.
Mrs Chaplin was switched to a desk job after she refused to take off a crucifix which hung round her neck, while Miss Ladele was disciplined by Islington council for refusing to conduct civil partnership ceremonies.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdMr McFarlane was dismissed from his role with the charity Relate after indicating he might have a conscientious objection to providing therapy to a same-sex couple.
The claimants attempted to take their appeals to the Grand Chamber of the Court but the judges have rejected their request.
Mrs Chaplin’s claims were rejected on the grounds that the removal of her necklace was necessary to protect the health and safety of nurses and patients.
Appeals by Miss Ladele and Mr McFarlane were dismissed on the grounds that disciplinary proceedings against them were justified.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdThe ruling stated that both Islington council and Relate were bound by duties not to discriminate against their clients and meant they could not support staff who refused to work with homosexual couples.
Keith Porteous Wood, executive director of the National Secular Society, said: “Fortunately, Europe’s highest court has now wisely followed numerous lower courts and rejected the applicants’ attempts for religious conscience to trump equality law.
“The UK has the world’s most comprehensive equality laws which already include strong protection for religious believers and they would have been fatally compromised, particularly for LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transexual) people had the Grand Chamber overturned any of these judgments.
“We hope that this will now draw a line under the attempts by a small coterie of Christian activists to obtain special privileges for themselves which would invariably come at the expense of other people’s rights.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad“The principle of equality for all, including for religious believers, is now established and they should stop wasting the time of the courts with these vexatious cases.”
The cases were rejected in January as another case – involving British Airways worker Nadia Eweida – was upheld.
Miss Eweida, a Coptic Christian, was sent home from work for displaying a small silver crucifix during her job as an airport check-in attendant for the airline.
The Strasbourg court ruled the decision to express her faith warranted protection under the European Convention on Human Rights and Miss Eweida been discriminated against under freedom of religion laws.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdBritish Humanist Association head of public affairs Pavan Dhaliwal said: “The only reason these cases have continued for so long is because of a determined lobby seeking to whip up a narrative of ‘Christian persecution’.
“However, this narrative is detached from the reality of simply trying to guarantee fair treatment for all, regardless of sexual orientation, and reasonable standards of health and safety.
“Of course religious beliefs should be accommodated by our laws and society, but not when those beliefs impinge upon the rights and freedoms of others, and that is what these cases sought to do. We hope that society can now move on and focus on more pressing concerns.”
Richard Watts, Islington Council’s executive councillor for Finance and Performance, said: “The council welcomes this decision.
“No public servant has the right to discriminate against people while performing their duties, and the council’s position on this matter was previously upheld by the British courts.”