It will take time and a lot of work to restore trust following the Sheffield tree scandal

When all those trees were wrongly chopped down in Sheffield, another thing that was also felled in the city was trust between campaigners desperately trying to save healthy trees and the authorities.

That trust is still absent today and will take a lot of time and work to restore. Let’s not forget that ordinary people were effectively criminalised for simply trying to stop the wanton destruction of their city.

The furore over the leader of Sheffield City Council’s incorrect response to a street tree campaigner’s complaint about protesters who were subjected to “illegitimate pressure “over a court threat highlights there’s a long way to go to heal relations between the council and wronged campaigners.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

When asked why a formal complaint from those illegitimately pressured to sign a draconian undertaking had so far taken three years to process, Tom Hunt responded in March that the complaint was not progressed in 2021.

A file photo of tree protests on Kenwood Road in the Nether Edge area of Sheffield. PIC: Scott MerryleesA file photo of tree protests on Kenwood Road in the Nether Edge area of Sheffield. PIC: Scott Merrylees
A file photo of tree protests on Kenwood Road in the Nether Edge area of Sheffield. PIC: Scott Merrylees

“This is because the independent street tree inquiry was announced at that time and it was felt that the inquiry was a better way of resolving the issues that were raised,” he added.

What he failed to include in his response was “and the council’s response to it”. The omission of just a few words caused consternation. It shows that councillors need to choose their words very carefully because trust is at a premium.

Mr Hunt is right to hold his hands up and correct the record. To be fair to him and council chief executive Kate Josephs, they weren’t the architects of the ill-judged tree felling plan and have repeatedly proffered apologies for the council’s actions following the Lowcock Report findings.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.