Yorkshire woman marries her childhood sweetheart - 24 years after she moved to US to get over their break-up

A woman who moved to the US to get over her first love has revealed her plan didn’t work – after they reunited 24 years later and got married.

Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18 after two years of dating.

The pair had grown up together as Jonathan and his family lived next door to Amanda’s grandparents in Middlesborough and she was best friends with his four sisters.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But after the young couple broke up, Amanda relocated to Arizona, US, in 1991, to move on from the relationship and ‘try something different’.

Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18
Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18

Amanda got married and had three sons, and although she stayed in touch with Jonathan’s mum and sisters, she ceased all contact with her ex.

When Amanda’s marriage broke down, she was left her thinking about Jonathan and how she ‘needed a man like him who could make her laugh’.

Jonathan - who was divorced and had a daughter from a previous relationship - added Amanda as a friend on Facebook out of the blue in October 2015, the pair began talking and instantly rekindled their love, before tying the knot in Las Vegas when he flew over to visit the following August.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

After eight years of marriage, the pair couldn’t be happier and believe they were ‘always meant to be’.

Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18
Amanda Piper, 49, split from childhood sweetheart, Jonathan, 52, when she was 18

Amanda, a supervisor, from Peoria, Arizona, US, said: “I don’t think you ever forget your first love – at least I didn’t. Sometimes I look at him and think: ‘I can’t believe it’s you.' We were always meant to be.”

Read More
Britain's Got Talent: Yorkshire busker took runners-up spot after declaring that...

Jonathan, a butcher, said: “We’d wasted enough time apart – when I flew over to the States, I knew I wanted to marry her. It was now or never.”

Amanda used to spend every weekend with her grandparents, Dorothy and Edward Coulthard, at their home in Middlesbrough.

The couple got married have now been married for eight yearsThe couple got married have now been married for eight years
The couple got married have now been married for eight years
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

She was best friends with Jayne Piper, now 48, who lived next door, and knew her family well – including her brother Jonathan.

Thinking of him only as ‘Jayne’s older brother’, the pair never spoke, until Amanda was around 15 and she ‘properly noticed him for the first time’.

“We started dating when I was about 16 – he was my first love,” Amanda said. "I would see him every weekend when I was with my nana and grandad, and I’d pop into his stepdad's butchers' shop after school to see him. He made me laugh so much.”

After two years together, the young couple split when Amanda was 18, and Jonathan met someone else and ‘moved on’.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Deciding she wanted a change, Amanda decided to make the huge move to America, and flew to Arizona in 1991 at the age of 19.

“I went to get over him and do something new,” Amanda said. “I just needed a change.”

Amanda stayed with her auntie and uncle, Marilyn and Steven Tullock, now 70, and two cousins, Clare, now 42, and Stacey, now 44, who already lived in the US, before meeting a man and getting married just a year later.

The pair went on to have three sons – Marcos, 29, Alex, 28, and Adam, 26 – and Amanda felt a huge sense of pride at taking control of her life and following her American dream.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Sadly, her relationship began to break down, and she split from her then-husband in early 2000's whilst their sons were still young but remained living together in order to co-parent their children.

“It was hard, but we did it for the boys,” Amanda said. “I was waiting for a sign that told me it was time to move out – and that’s when Jonathan messaged me.”

Amanda received a friend request from Jonathan Piper in October 2015 - 24 years after the pair had last spoken.

“I had been thinking that I needed a man like him in my life, someone who made me laugh – and then he appeared. It was like it was fate,” Amanda said. “It was surreal, but it was like nothing had changed.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Amanda flew back to the UK to see Jonathan in January 2016, before he returned the favour and flew to Arizona in May.

He stayed for as long as his tourist visa would allow – three months – before the pair decided they had ‘wasted enough time apart’ and got married on 13th August 2016.

“I just knew I couldn’t let him go this time,” Amanda said. “Our families flew over to celebrate and we went to Vegas to get married. It felt surreal, but like the stars had finally aligned.”

With the help of lawyers, Jonathan was approved for a green card to stay in the United States, where the two still live happily eight years later.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“Sometimes he’ll be sat there watching TV and I just say: ‘I can’t believe it’s you'," Amanda said. “He laughs, but it still feels special after all this time. You’ve got to trust your heart.”

“I never pictured myself living in America, but it’s what you do for love,” Jonathan added. “I took a gamble when I messaged her after all that time – but luckily it paid off and we happened to still feel the same way. I never forgot about her.”