Public perception

Though Shaun Wright’s argument that more officers should wear their uniforms will chime with public opinion, it is his duty to ensure that he pays full regard to the personal safety of his entire workforce.

There are many occasions when undercover police work requires the cloak of anonymity in order to apprehend offenders and this must not be compromised.

There are also risks associated with asking civilian officers to wear fluorescent jacket if they leave the police station; there will be some members of the public who will inevitably mistake them for fully fledged officers.

And South Yorkshire Police needs to consider whether an upgrading of its corporate identity should be a financial priority at a time when it is facing huge financial pressures – and the likelihood of even further cuts – following last week’s Budget.

That said, Mr Wright – and his senior officers – do have a point when they point out the extent to which dress standards have slipped.

The issue is whether this is a consequence of Tony Blair’s decision to favour a casual look when in public, a fashion trend that has been followed by most politicians, or a reflection of police standards because officers simply do not have the time – or inclination – to follow past protocols.

As such, some will conclude that the primary issue is not the attire of South Yorkshire’s officers but their ability to do the job and protect the public at all times.