Sheffield United's Chris Wilder joins disapproval as FA Cup replays are scrapped in schedule changes

Football League clubs have voiced their anger after FA Cup replays were scrapped, and in Sheffield United's Chris Wilder they have the support of a Premier League manager.

As of 2024-25 there will be no replays in the competition proper, one of a number of changes after the Football Association’s six-year deal with the Premier League.

The decision was made “in light of changes to the calendar driven by the expanded UEFA competitions”. No one playing in the first two rounds are involved in these.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Next season’s Champions League has 64 more games and it, the Europa and Conference Leagues each have a midweek to themselves.

Despite that, all FA Cup ties will be on “weekends” – although that is laughably defined as from Friday to Wednesday. The final will be on the penultimate Saturday of the Premier League season.

The Premier League's winter break – half-hearted at best this season – will be scrapped to allow for a "mid-August" start.

It is the scrapping of replays and lack of consultation Football League chief executive Trevor Birch called “frustrating and disappointing”. His clubs will be “seeking appropriate compensation” although the FA has promised to add £33m to the £100m it provides to grassroots football.

OPPOSITION: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder was in favour of keeping FA Cup replaysOPPOSITION: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder was in favour of keeping FA Cup replays
OPPOSITION: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder was in favour of keeping FA Cup replays
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Wilder, whose first managerial job was with North Counties East side Alfreton Town before joining Halifax Town, criticised the move.

“The game is dictated and dominated by the big boys and the big boys don't want FA Cup replays, do they?” he said.

“What does that do to non-league clubs getting to the fairytale world of round three? Clubs have had FA Cup runs and replays that have financially benefited them for the next five years.

“I am a traditionalist and would have liked it kept the same but the game is moving on so you have to go with what gets decided.”

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.