'Act to stop this nightmare': Government and HMRC must show they are serious about ending loan charge scandal, says MP

The Financial Conduct Authority says it has acted to protect consumers who are facing demands for disguised remuneration scheme loan repayments.

An FCA spokesman said it had agreed restrictions with Ethica Resolve, an FCA authorised firm that services and collects debt on behalf of creditors, to protect consumers facing repayment demands. This follows demands it made for people to repay loans, or purported loans, provided as part of disguised remuneration schemes, the FCA said.

The FCA took the action after concerns were raised by MPs about “deeply worrying” reports that people are facing fresh demands to repay loans that HMRC has demanded they pay income tax on.

Disguised remuneration schemes saw people – often contractors, consultants and agency workers – paid for their work through loans instead of regular salaries.

Library image of loan charge campaigners outside Parliament. Greg Smith MP, Co-Chair of the Loan Charge & Taxpayer Fairness APPG said: “It’s deeply worrying that people are facing fresh demands to repay loans that HMRC has demanded they pay income tax on. This is creating a further serious mental health crisis for those affected yet HMRC and the Government and are doing nothing to stop this. Whilst it is positive that the FCA has made contact with one of the entities involved, this doesn’t resolve this issue, which is what is needed." (Photo supplied by Loan Charge Action Group)placeholder image
Library image of loan charge campaigners outside Parliament. Greg Smith MP, Co-Chair of the Loan Charge & Taxpayer Fairness APPG said: “It’s deeply worrying that people are facing fresh demands to repay loans that HMRC has demanded they pay income tax on. This is creating a further serious mental health crisis for those affected yet HMRC and the Government and are doing nothing to stop this. Whilst it is positive that the FCA has made contact with one of the entities involved, this doesn’t resolve this issue, which is what is needed." (Photo supplied by Loan Charge Action Group)

HMRC recently confirmed that some taxpayers may have been contacted by a third party about repaying a loan that they took out through a disguised remuneration tax avoidance scheme.

In addition to receiving a demand for repayment, taxpayers may also be liable for the loan charge. The Government recently established a new settlement opportunity for those with outstanding loan charge liabilities following a review conducted by Ray McCann, a former President of the Chartered Institute of Taxation.

The FCA spokesman added: “Ethica will write to affected consumers to explain that they do not need to make a payment in response to the repayment demand at this stage.

"There are restrictions on Ethica making further payment demands and seeking default judgments while the outstanding legal and regulatory issues are resolved.”

Ethica is acting on behalf of West 28th Street Limited (West 28), which bought disguised remuneration loans from a third party. West 28 is not authorised or regulated by the FCA, the spokesman said.

The FCA said there had been positive feedback on the action it had taken from some of the people impacted.

Greg Smith MP, co-chair of the Loan Charge & Taxpayer Fairness All Party Parliamentary Group, said: “It’s deeply worrying that people are facing fresh demands to repay loans that HMRC has demanded they pay income tax on. This is creating a further serious mental health crisis for those affected yet HMRC and the Government and are doing nothing to stop this.

"Whilst it is positive that the FCA has made contact with one of the entities involved, this doesn’t resolve this issue, which is what is needed.

Mr Smith, the Conservative MP for Mid Buckinghamshire who is also Shadow Minister of State for Transport, added: “As the APPG has stated previously, if HMRC are allowed to declare that these loans were always income, then the Government should have simultaneously legislated to prevent these sorts of loan repayment demands.

"One of the many parts of the loan charge scandal is the fact that HMRC has treated these payments simultaneously as income and as loans, including imposing inheritance tax as well as income tax, which is grossly unfair and leaves this ongoing uncertainty.

“Government Ministers have publicly stated that those caught up in the loan charge scandal are victims of mis-selling, yet as well as failing to go after the perpetrators of that mis-selling, they are doing nothing to protect the same victims from these dubious and dangerous repayment claims.

"If the Government and HMRC were serious about bringing the loan charge scandal to an end, they would act to stop this nightmare at the same time as providing a fair resolution, which they still have not done for the majority of those affected”.

An HMRC spokesperson said: “We are aware that some individuals are being contacted by a third party about repaying loans taken out as part of disguised remuneration arrangements. We understand this may be distressing for those affected, particularly for anyone who believed they would not be asked to repay the loans.

“Those affected should seek independent legal advice from a professional with the relevant experience and knowledge, and we have published guidance on GOV.UK to support people who may be affected.”

Ethica Resolve and West 28th Street Limited did not respond to repeated requests to comment.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice