Raising capital gains tax would scare off vital investment in our businesses: David Richards

In recent weeks I have met investors across Sheffield, Leeds and London, and time after time they say the same thing: “If they put it up, we’re off.” They mean capital gains tax.

The Budget is on October 28, the three biggest taxes, income tax, VAT and national insurance, are off the table, and CGT is reported to be the favourite for a rise. The chancellor, John Healey, told the Sunday Times that Britain has the “lowest capital gains tax of any European G7 nation”.

Politicians rarely mention such facts unless they mean to change something.

A founder takes less salary than they could earn elsewhere, sometimes for years, and works for shares that could become worthless, while investors back a portfolio of companies knowing that many will fail, leaving the returns from the successes to cover the losses. The return has to justify the bet.

David Richards pictured at the Cutlers Hall, Sheffield. Picture taken by Yorkshire Post Photographer Simon Hulmeplaceholder image
David Richards pictured at the Cutlers Hall, Sheffield. Picture taken by Yorkshire Post Photographer Simon Hulme

EIS and SEIS offer real relief to qualifying investors in start-ups, but not every founder or every funding round qualifies, and loss relief cushions a failure without repaying the investment or covering the salary forgone. Now imagine 45 per cent on the gain, as those campaigning for alignment with the top income tax rate want.

Ten-year gilts yield about 5.4 per cent, close to their highest since 2007, so the government invites investors to lend it money and at the same time considers penalising the alternative.

The headline rate is not the whole burden either. After corporation tax, 75p remains from each pound of profit. Suppose retaining that profit adds 75p to the value of the shares; a 45 per cent tax on the resulting gain takes another 34p, and almost 59p of the original pound has gone to HMRC. There is no allowance for inflation. Prices have risen more than 40 per cent since 2016, so selling for 40 per cent above what you paid then yields no real gain. The Treasury still taxes the nothing.

When Nigel Lawson aligned the rates in 1988 he argued that “there is little economic difference between income and capital gains”. But he taxed only the gain in excess of inflation. Ten years later Gordon Brown replaced indexation with taper relief, and by 2002 holding business assets for two years brought the effective rate down to 10 per cent. How the gain was treated mattered as much as the rate.

HMRC’s own ready reckoner of June 2025 estimated that a ten-point increase in the higher rate would lose £540 million in year one, rising beyond £3.5 billion by year three. This year’s edition was scheduled for July 7. It was postponed the day before for a review of its assumptions.

Tax due for 2024-25 totalled £24.2 billion, up 89 per cent, helped by investors selling before the most recent rise. Timing matters. Faced with a higher rate, an investor can simply defer the sale.

There is an obvious criticism of the status quo: the gap encourages people paid for their work to arrange to receive it as capital gains. Carried interest was the prominent case. Britain moved it into income tax in April, at a reduced rate. Fix that problem. It does not make every founder’s gain a disguised salary.

Higher rates push money into gilts, lock it in place or send it abroad. British pension funds allocate roughly 4 per cent to domestic shares, and overseas investors own nearly 60 per cent of the quoted market. The investors I met have options. Nothing obliges them to write the next cheque.

For a UK growth firm waiting on that cheque, the money means another member of staff, a bigger workshop or a new product. The investor can opt out. The business must find another backer or put its plans on hold.

That is who the chancellor should bear in mind while working out how much more to take.

David Richards MBE is managing partner of Yorkshire AI Labs

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice