The hidden self-image identity gap holding new leaders back: Ali Archbold
Ask anyone promoted to lead their former teammates how the first few months felt, and you’ll rarely hear “easy”.
I know that first-hand. Early in my career, I became team leader over friends and colleagues. I knew the job, I knew the team and I was good at what I did. But suddenly, I was expected to lead people who had previously been my equals. I found the shift far harder than anyone had warned me about.
The job changes overnight, but your self-image doesn’t necessarily change with it.
More than 20 years later, that experience has helped shape my Leeds-based leadership development and coaching business, Optability, and I call this ‘The Identity Gap’.


With almost 10 million people in the UK working as people managers, it’s a challenge that will be familiar to businesses across Yorkshire and beyond.
A technical expert must suddenly delegate. A team leader who wants to be liked must hold former colleagues to account. A newly-appointed director might look the part on paper but quietly question whether they belong in the room.
These people aren’t necessarily short of ability or ambition. They might simply still see themselves as the person they were before the promotion.
The CIPD’s 2024 Good Work Index found one in four employees surveyed in the North of England had experienced workplace conflict in the previous year.
Navigating relationships and difficult conversations is an important part of leadership, yet these can be particularly challenging when someone is still finding their feet and ‘who they are’ in a new role.
Of course, leaders need to learn how to delegate, give feedback and manage performance. But knowing what to do and feeling able to do it are two different things.
You can know exactly how to have a difficult conversation and still avoid it because you’re worried about upsetting someone. You can attend a delegation workshop and still take everything back because, deep down, you believe it’s safer to do it yourself.
When we measure our worth by how much we personally achieve, letting go can feel like losing what made us successful. We work harder, take too much on or avoid difficult conversations, potentially holding back both ourselves and our teams.
We’re often promoted because we’re good at doing the job. But leading people is a different job altogether.
My approach is rooted in behavioural psychology and helps people explore the gap between how they see themselves today and the leader they need to become. I break this down into three stages:
Stepping In means understanding where you are now: how you see yourself, your strengths and the experiences that have shaped you.
Stepping Out involves questioning what might be holding you back, from outdated beliefs about your value to habits that once served you well but no longer help.
Stepping Up means drawing on your strengths, ambition and sense of purpose to develop a way of leading that feels both effective and authentic.
It’s not about becoming someone else. It’s about recognising that the qualities that got you here might need to be expressed differently in your new role.
I experienced this again when I became self-employed. My professional identity had to catch up with my new reality as I took responsibility for my own business, decisions and direction.
I talk openly about these experiences because I believe leadership development should make space for honesty, not just polished success stories.
I’m now piloting an Identity Gap self-assessment to help people explore where the gap between their self-image and leadership ambitions might be widest. It’s a starting point for reflection and conversation, not a verdict.
My message to businesses across the region is straightforward. If you’re promoting good people and they’re not flourishing, look beyond their skills. Most people who struggle after stepping up aren’t short of ability, they’re still leading as the person they used to be.
Help them see who they’re becoming, and the skills finally have somewhere to land.
Ali Archbold is founder and lead consultant at Optability, a Leeds-based leadership development, coaching and advisory business