Why Yorkshire's NHS trusts need to start preparing for Hillsborough Law impacts: David Birch
More than three decades after the Hillsborough disaster, it is still shaping our understanding of accountancy and transparency between individuals and the state.
The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, better known as the Hillsborough Law, will introduce a statutory duty of candour and assistance for public servants and authorities when engaging with inquiries, inquests and similar investigations.
It also seeks to introduce a new framework for ethical conduct, new criminal offences and it seeks to introduce “parity of representation” for bereaved families through non-means-tested legal aid where a public authority is an interested person.
As the Bill moves closer to becoming law, the focus is shifting from the principles behind the reforms to what they’ll mean in practice.


For public authorities, and the NHS in particular, the implications could be considerable. Government estimates suggest eligibility for legal aid in connection with an inquest could increase from around 200–400 cases annually to approximately 11,400. While that figure rests on several assumptions, there is no doubt significantly more families will have legal representation at inquests.
The case for families having access to legal representation is clear but there may also be unintended consequences for NHS staff and organisations across the country, including Yorkshire’s 21 NHS Trusts.
Greater legal representation is likely to change the way many inquests are conducted, potentially moving them from the intended inquisitorial focus to a more adversarial (legal) approach. We expect increased pressure upon coroners to call more witnesses, more arguments around Article 2 – which can broaden an inquest’s examination to consider the wider circumstances surrounding a death – and greater focus on potential systemic failings.
This will place additional demands on already stretched NHS resources through disclosure, witness and expert evidence, and disputes over the scope and conduct of hearings. There will also be cases where the NHS requires legal representation in response to the approach taken by the family’s legal representatives.
Healthcare adds particular complexity because a person’s needs are rarely delivered by one organisation in isolation. A patient may encounter ambulance crews, hospital specialties, GPs, mental health services, social care and independent providers.
Establishing who knew what, when decisions were made, and whether information was properly shared can already make for a complex or lengthy inquest. Greater legal representation is likely to bring those relationships under much closer examination.
For NHS staff, this will mean further demands on their time. Preparing evidence requires healthcare staff to review records, write statements, and spend time away from frontline care.
More witnesses being approached and a closer testing of evidence will add to those pressures. While the impact of death on the bereaved family is the primary consideration, as they have lost a loved one, but it is important to also acknowledge the impact that a death and inquest can have upon the staff who were caring for that person, doing their best in often challenging situations.
There are financial implications too. NHS organisations could face additional staffing and legal costs, while the Bill’s economic impact assessment estimates non-means-tested aid could cost £65m – £180m. The policy intention is for these costs to be met by the sponsoring departments of relevant public authorities – the Department of Health and Social Care in the NHS’s case – potentially placing further pressure on healthcare budgets.
Yorkshire’s NHS Trusts therefore need to prepare now. They should identify cases likely to attract greater scrutiny, involve Article 2 or require significant legal resource, while reviewing disclosure processes, clinician support and capacity across legal, governance and patient safety teams.
Boards must also recognise that inquests can no longer be viewed simply as legal matters. Their implications for patient safety, workforce, finances and reputation make them an organisation-wide issue.
The Hillsborough Law is a landmark reform and its ambition to give families greater access to answers and accountability should be welcomed. The challenge now is ensuring greater accountability works without placing unsustainable pressure on the people and services expected to deliver it.
David Birch is a partner and healthcare specialist at law firm Weightmans