Time to get tough on the irresponsible dog owners - Stuart Minting

News that dog owners will soon face unlimited fines if they allow their pets to be in a position to worry livestock has been widely welcomed.

After the move to toughen penalties and expanding protections cleared Parliament’s Upper Chamber, Tory peer Lord Colgrain described it as “the best possible Christmas present to all livestock owners”.

It is important to remember who the legislation is targeting. Dog owners have had reminders as to how their pets should be controlled fixed to gates and styles for many years.

On top of that there have been successive high-profile campaigns emphasising the consequences of sheep worrying.

Sheep in farm landscape on sunny dayplaceholder image
Sheep in farm landscape on sunny day

As well as raising the limit on fines and changing the definition of livestock to include animals such as camelids, the legislation will see paths and even roads brought into the scope of the Dogs (Protection of Livestock) Act 1953 and police handed extra powers to seize dogs.

The move follows years of mounting concerns over sheep worrying incidents and dozens of sheep being killed, and many more injured, in dog attacks across Yorkshire annually.

The National Sheep Association estimates 15,000 sheep are killed by dogs every year across the country and barely a month goes by without a farm in the region being hit with a horrific incident.

A Scottish study has found the average time farmers spent dealing with a single sheep attack incident was over five hours, including the time spent rounding up and checking on scattered sheep, re-mothering lambs with ewes and repairing fences.

However, like many rural crimes, fines and prosecutions appear as rare as hen’s teeth.

If the change is to represent a truly meaningful step forward for rural commuties it’s essential that police properly publicise cases, particularly as the threat of fines is yet to impact on the issue.

The publicity irresponsible dog owners would get could be more unwanted than a fine.

Earlier this year an NFU Mutual study revealed the total cost of livestock worrying across the UK had fallen to £1.8 million from £2.4 million the previous year.

That’s still an astonishing and completely unacceptable cost, but many farmers are quick to point towards the broader impact attacks on livestock have on the rural community.

So much so that victims regularly voice a desire that the dog owner learns from the incident and perpetrators are simply handed a caution.

By approving the law changes to tackle sheep worrying, peers and MPs conditional discharges are underlining that the status quo is unacceptable.

Tough action rather than just tougher threats are needed to achieve societal change.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice