NHS trust is urged to tackle ‘toxic culture’ of bullying at hospitals
Hospitals at the centre of allegations of a “toxic culture” have been urged to tackle bullying after it was raised repeatedly by staff in an independent review.
The review team said the evidence was a “serious cause for concern” for Doncaster and Bassetlaw Hospitals NHS trust.
A “disconnect” between service-level workers and bosses was also uncovered at the organisation, as well as claims financial savings were being prioritised over quality and patient care.
Trust leaders have accepted the findings of the review and its 13 recommendations for change.


Separately, trust staff were informed last week its chief executive Richard Parker is on long-term sick leave and interim leadership arrangements are in place.
Earlier this month, the trust announced its medical director Tim Noble had been dismissed after an independent panel found its employment relationship with him had “broken down irreparably”.
The British Medical Association had previously revealed he had made allegations of bullying and harassment at the organisation which the union claimed had a “toxic culture”.
The review by thevaluecircle was ordered by hospital leaders last April in the wake of public concerns over the trust’s culture.
It said “many staff shared examples of inappropriate behaviour from colleagues, managers and senior managers” including bullying.
In one small survey of 300 staff, half reported being bullied or harassed.
The report said concerns were “raised repeatedly…and examples were given on all three sites visited, across a large range of staff groups of behaviour that was described as bullying or harassment”.
“This clearly indicates a serious cause for concern for the trust, and the review team are sure the trust will wish to take action to better understand and address it.”
It urged the trust to identify hotspots for bullying and intervene where required.
The report said many staff felt a strong connection to their immediate team and most were proud of the care they provided
“However, many staff caveated this pride with a concern. They worry the increasing operational pressures on services, in the face of a continued focus on cost improvement, could compromise safety of care,” it said.
Some said this was already happening linked to reduced staffing and rundown buildings.
Staff shared examples of concerns raised with the trust through official channels but these appeared to “‘enter a void or black hole’” when raised with senior managers.
Morale and care quality were also being affected by the poor quality of buildings particularly at Doncaster Royal Infirmary.
In a statement, trust leaders said work was underway to address findings including clarifying expectations around behaviour and standards and improving communication.
Interim chair Mark Bailey said: “Much of this builds on work that is already underway or planned and the review helps sharpen our focus on where further action is needed.”
Staff were told last week that interim leadership arrangements are in place until the end of March due to chief executive Richard Parker’s absence with illness. A former nurse, he has been chief executive since 2017.