As we welcome in the New Year we may be looking forward to experiencing new things - and for foodies that means new restaurants.
But when we say new, we mean restaurants that some of us may have never visited before, despite receiving plenty of praise from diners who have had the pleasure of enjoying a meal at them.
We have a guide to the most popular restaurants across South Yorkshire that you need to visit in 2026 - and what diners had to say about their experience.
The restaurants included come from OpenTable’s ‘Diner’s Choice’ list, which are the most booked in the county - updated in January 2026.
5. The Stable Door, High Melton
The Stable Door in High Melton has a 4.9* rating from 128 reviews. An OpenTable reviewer said: “Five star experience. No negative comments from us. The food, staff, and the restaurant was extremely busy but was given first class service. Will be definitely booking again in the not too distant future.” | OpenTable
6. La Boca, Doncaster
La Boca in Doncaster has a 4.8* rating from 1,865 reviews. An OpenTable reviewer said: “Another great meal again last night. Never disappointed when we visit. Great place, great staff, great food.” | Tripadvisor
7. Elm, Sheffield
Elm in Sheffield has a 4.9* rating from 53 reviews. An OpenTable reviewer said: “Amazing food. Really interesting menu with great mix of dishes. And fantastic service! Will be back.” | Google Maps
8. La Rustica, Doncaster
La Rustica in Doncaster has a 4.8* rating from 1,086 reviews. An OpenTable reviewer said: “Absolutely outstanding service from Ecu and team. We were made to feel very welcome and they went over and above. Food was delish. If I could score 10 stars I would!” | La Rustica, Doncaster