Melton's, York: 'I ate at TripAdvisor's best fine dining restaurant in the UK - it's very, very good'

Melton’s is a treasured York institution that has been around for 35 years. Jill Turton paid a long overdue return visit and found that, if anything, the food has got even better.

From the outside, Melton’s is unremarkable, a neighbourhood restaurant in a suburban street just outside York’s city walls.

Yet last year, the owners, Michael and Lucy Hjort marked up 35 years at Melton’s, a remarkable achievement and in that time, they’ve barely put a foot wrong.

From its earliest days, Melton’s featured in all the reputable guides but last year was one of their best, they were named Best of the Best in the TripAdvisor awards for a year of positive reviews and gained three rosettes from the AA.

When Melton’s first opened in 1990, they pitched themselves as a relaxed Anglo/French restaurant with Michael Hjort at the stove producing good food with the emphasis on regional and seasonal ingredients while Lucy ran the front of house and built up an excellent cellar.

You might think after 35 years Melton’s would have settled into a tired old groove, but not so.

Through the years, they have kept it modern and relevant, never more so than in the last few years after they made some radical changes.

Michael moved across town to run the Chopping Block, their casual restaurant and bar on Walmgate and Calvin Miller took over as head chef at Melton’s.

Miller has created two menus, a Short Menu (£85 for three courses) and a Tasting Menu (£98 for six courses). And it’s very, very good.

Melton's Restaurant, Scarcroft Road, York, was named the best fine dining restaurant in the UK by TripAdivisor in 2025. Picture: James Hardisty.placeholder image
Melton's Restaurant, Scarcroft Road, York, was named the best fine dining restaurant in the UK by TripAdivisor in 2025. Picture: James Hardisty.

The Short Menu turns out not as short as it first appears.

First they send out canapes: a little cup of beef tartare, a teeny beetroot tart and a squid ink cracker filled with whipped cod’s roe with the zing of yuzu. All of them are fabulous.

This is followed by an ‘amuse bouche’ of something light and fluffy with cauliflower, pine nuts, crispy capers and mint.

There is bread too, a chewy, damp, sourdough with two butters: piquillo pepper and a terrific nutty, beurre noisette.

None of these are listed on the Short Menu, and I’m beginning to think this might be special treatment – chefs are known for sending out extra dishes to reviewers, but I’m assured this is no special treatment ‘Everyone gets the same,’ says Lucy, ‘it just gives the kitchen time to prepare.’

Blackberry & Meadowsweet - Almond Cake, Yoghurt. Picture: James Hardistyplaceholder image
Blackberry & Meadowsweet - Almond Cake, Yoghurt. Picture: James Hardisty

It gives us time to study the wine list. It’s a volume of 180+ wines at prices ranging from £26 to £200 plus, with most bottles averaging a manageable £45.

But forget the list, I commend anyone eating here to ask, as we did, for Lucy’s advice. She knows her wine, is good at pairing wine with food and has an affable approach free of intimidating wine-speak.

For my starter of Jerusalem artichoke, immersed in a creamy truffle sauce and studded with hazelnut and buckwheat, she advises a Swartland Reign of Terroir, Chenin Blanc from South Africa, and she’s right. It works beautifully with the nuttiness and the sweetness of the artichoke.

My pal Janette, who is the driver, carefully makes her one small glass of the light, red Austrian Zweigelt, last through both her starter of Orkney scallop as well as her main.

It goes well with the scallop, the tang of the verjus, offset by maple syrup and a splash of meat stock.

Red Deer - Celeriac, Elderberry, Quince. Picture: James Hardisty.placeholder image
Red Deer - Celeriac, Elderberry, Quince. Picture: James Hardisty.

But Lucy is most excited by a robust Epicuria Cabernet Sauvignon from Morocco. She found it by accident when a customer brought it in for her to try.

She knew it would be perfect with venison, but it took months for her to track down enough bottles to put on her list.

I’m glad she persevered, because its ripe red fruit with a touch of sweetness matches my venison loin and elderberry ketchup.

There is a soft, slow-cooked venison faggot on the plate too, a slice of quince tart, black pudding puree, buttery sliced potato, celeriac and a venison jus. It’s an outstanding dish and the wine a virtuous match.

There are three desserts. A wobbly, well-risen prune and brandy souffle goes wafting by to another table, but I go for the Blackberry and Meadowsweet and Janette, the ‘Huila 70% chocolate, coconut, kaffir lime and fig leaf.’

Huila, I can tell you (after Googling) is a ‘single origin dark chocolate from Colombia with a slightly floral flavour and hints of citrus’.

Chef Miller has created a handsome-looking chocolate bombe that breaks open with an agreeable crack to reveal a coconut puree, coconut crisps and sharp kaffir lime. On top, fig leaf ice cream that oddly has a mild flavour of coconut.

Orkney Scallop - Crown Prince Squash, Maple Verjus, Furikake. Picture: James Hardistyplaceholder image
Orkney Scallop - Crown Prince Squash, Maple Verjus, Furikake. Picture: James Hardisty

If a dessert were invented for Instagram, it would be Calvin Miller’s ‘Blackberry and Meadowsweet’. It’s up there on his feed, with all his beautifully photographed dishes, a symphony in purple.

It starts with a swirl of purple syrup. On top is a dark elderberry parfait and a blackberry and yoghurt ripple.

There are lightly pickled blackberries and for contrast cubes of almond cake soaked in honey and meadowsweet. Who knew the fluffy flowers of the summer hedgerow would make it to my plate in downtown York?

The cheesecake-like mascarpone custard is in contrast with the richness of the berries. A crisp sugar tuile stands like a shard of glass and finally, oxalis leaves sit like mini purple butterflies about to take flight.

It’s a tour de force from this ambitious chef.

If, like me, you’ve neglected Melton’s just because it’s been there forever, then I commend you to take another look. If you’ve never been, you’re in for a treat.

Miller’s menu is more exciting and more refined than I remember but still with the Melton’s ethos created by Michael and Lucy Hjort, a modest couple without ego, who know how to welcome their guests, provide good food, good wine, decent portions in friendly, unfussy surroundings just as they’ve been doing for the last 35 years. Long may they continue.

Welcome 5/5

Food 5/5

Atmosphere 4/5

Prices 5/5

Melton’s Restaurant, 7 Scarcroft Road, York YO23 1ND

meltonsrestaurant.co.uk

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice