Smithfield restaurant review: Standards very high from new owners of former Reliance in Leeds
Jill Turton paid a visit to the Smithfield in Leeds, formerly the Reliance, and found the new owners are successfully carrying on the high standards, but the noise was a bit too much...
Before it was the Smithfield, it was the Reliance a much-loved bar/dining room on North Street, Leeds. It opened in 2000, turning a seedy old caff into what became one of Leeds’ first gastropubs. They stripped the floors, added mismatched furniture and painted the outside blood red and served ham hock terrine, pork chops and their own charcuterie, the beer was good too. Then in January 2023, to the dismay of their regulars, they sold up and moved on.
Three’s A Crowd buzzed in from Harrogate, painted the outside blue and, after no time at all, they moved on too.
Next came Sheffield lad James Donovan. He’d been cooking at London’s cool Rochelle Canteen before heading north to chum up with Steve Dawson of Crooked Brewing, an artisan brewery in Church Fenton with two bars, the Crooked Tap in Acomb and Driffield.


They named it the Smithfield, repainted it the old ‘Reliance Red’ and served Crooked Brewing craft ales, meals and bar snacks like ox tongue sandwiches, chicken wings and we spotted fabulous-looking doorstep toasties, flying out of the kitchen.
The dining room looks the same as it ever did. Big windows, high ceilings, wooden tables, rustic floorboards and as before, absolutely nothing to deaden the noise. It started fine, but by the end of our meal, the clatter from the kitchen and the ever-increasing chatter from a full dining room made it borderline impossible. The young ‘uns may not mind, but our conversation gradually died until we were back in the bar and could hear each other again.
There are no complaints about the menu, which starts with small bites, moving in size and price to more substantial dishes. Dishes, the waiter tells us, come from the open kitchen as and when they are ready. Blah blah, you know the drill.
The substantial dishes are chicken pie, pork chop with cider sauce and a special, of wild sea bass for sharing. If £54 sounds a lot for a (whole) fish, and it surely is, we all know fish is expensive, but order chips and grilled hispi cabbage, and two of you could eat for a reasonable 65 quid.


We snack first on whipped cod’s roe, dipping fiery radishes into the silky roe. We smear crunchy pigs’ head croquettes with the tartar-like sauce gribiche. So far, so excellent. We had already spied huge slabs of ‘house focaccia’ on the pass, all golden and glistening with sea salt crystals. It was the perfect vehicle for mopping up the remains of the cod’s roe.
Marginally bigger dishes included stuffed squid, chicken liver parfait and a seasonal asparagus with poached egg and finely grated parmesan - nicely cooked and presented. The crab crumpet bisque was outstanding. A soft crumpet heaped with sweet fresh white crab meat and finely diced tomato and what I think was thinly sliced fennel. The crumpet sat in a puddle of heady bisque, made rich and strong from the brown crab meat. Divvying it up between three was tricky; we should have ordered more. One of the awkward things about sharing plates is knowing the size of the dish. Will it be too much or not enough?
We were expecting our next dish to be smoked aubergine with chilli, hazelnut and labneh. It sounded good. Instead came the ‘herb-fed’ chicken pie. This was impressive. The size of a dinner plate with a stout pastry case, nicely crimped edges, and glazed and baked to a deep amber. Inside, tender poached chicken and smoked pig’s cheek had been braised in a sauce lifted with the aniseed notes of tarragon. The ‘buttery greens’, served with the pie, were less successful. Roughly chopped, and doused in melted butter, they were still tough old cabbage leaves.
While still on the pie, out came the smoked aubergine dish. Aubergine with labneh, preserved lemon and hazelnut was a composite dish, nice looking, well conceived, but it just didn’t work on the same plate as the chicken pie.


I’ve moaned before about sharing plates. Dishes that come out in a nonsensical order. Long gaps between courses that leave you feeling underfed. Dishes too small to share or an unbalanced meal, maybe too much protein, not enough veg. But I think I’ve cracked it.
A few days after dining at Smithfield, I ate at the Nettle at Settle (Yorkshire Post, January 2026). It’s another small plate menu with a dozen dishes. There were far too many for five of us to put together a balanced meal with enough to feed us all happily. So we told them, you decide. Bring us your best dishes.
And they did. And brilliantly. They created a meal that was well balanced, well-paced, the right size in the right order. We started with vegetable dishes and built gently towards fish and meat. It was far better than anything we would have put together ourselves.
Smithfield has excellent dishes on the menu, beautifully executed in the open kitchen. We finished with two lovely desserts, a prune and almond tart and an intensely chocolatey chocolate fondant. The drivers drank Northern Monk’s zero Faith hazy pale ale, the non-driver, a Sanziana Rose from Transylvania from a short list.
There were a few missteps along the way, call them teething troubles. The acoustics are something they might address, but the Smithfield is a worthy successor to the Reliance; the informal bar with good ales and wines from Wayward Wines with food that is interesting and when they get the pace right, very good. It is served by friendly, personable staff and all without breaking the bank.
Next time though, I’m going to ask them to put together my dinner, to choose their best dishes or to misquote Withnail and I, I will demand that they bring me the finest dishes available to humanity. I’m confident they will.
Welcome – 5/5
Food – 5/5
Atmosphere – 3/5
Prices – 5/5
The Smithfield, 76-78 North Street, Leeds LS2 7PN www.thesmithfieldleeds.com