The Owl, Hawnby: 'I braved snow and storms to eat at this glorious Yorkshire pub - and it was worth the trip'

Elaine Lemm and her husband decided to brave the foul weather to enjoy a meal at The Owl Hawnby… and discovered that they were the only diners but that didn’t deflect from some great cooking.

There’s no denying Storm Goretti, the first named weather beast to hit Yorkshire this year, caused some havoc.

Despite my fears of being snowed in, it never materialised where I live up near the North York Moors.

Just as well - I had a table booked at The Owl at Hawnby, and I hate cancelling at the last minute, something that can seriously impact a restaurant.

The Owl at Hawnby. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
The Owl at Hawnby. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpe

We had kept an eye on the weather all day and, though it was borderline what my late mum would have described as “you wouldn’t put a dog out on a night like this,” we were convinced that if we stuck to the main roads, albeit the long way round for us, we’d be fine.

And we were, until we turned off the A170 at the top of Sutton Bank. In no time, we were on snow-covered, ungritted roads.

Too late to turn back, and not fair to cancel. I gave The Owl a quick ring to check how it was in the village and was told it wasn’t bad, just a little slippery.

From the busy background noise I could hear, we were encouraged to carry on. How wrong we were.

The Owl at Hawnby. Toulouse sausage, lentils, cavolo, grape mustard and celeriac remoulade. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
The Owl at Hawnby. Toulouse sausage, lentils, cavolo, grape mustard and celeriac remoulade. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpe

When we arrived, The Owl shone into the dark night like a warm, welcoming beacon, and I, for one, was buoyed up.

There was a roaring fire and several people gathered around the bar, but to my surprise, not a single diner in the bar or the restaurant.

Eventually, the noisy group dispersed, leaving just a few stragglers and the staff. We remained the only two in the place for a while, until another couple arrived later.

Thankfully, I know The Owl and have seen it at its busiest, so we decided to crack on.

The Owl at Hawnby. Shortrib burger, Ogleshield cheese and bone marrow onions. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
The Owl at Hawnby. Shortrib burger, Ogleshield cheese and bone marrow onions. Picture Jonathan Gawthorpe

My keenness to revisit stemmed from hearing about a new chef replacing Sam Varley, who had breathed new life and renown into the place after, shall we say politely, a rough patch.

Sam remains involved, as The Owl is run as a joint venture between his family and the Owl’s landlord, Mexborough Estates.

New chef Will Rough brings with him an impressive CV, including stints at Skosh in York and The Star at Harome — both right up there in my favourites box - and he has been at Sam’s side for several months before taking over the reins.

Reading the menu for the first time, I’ll admit to being a little underwhelmed by it, though I genuinely wasn’t expecting either The Skosh or The Star on offer.

Will had said when he was first appointed that he wanted to keep the essence of traditional pub fare while also elevating the offering.

On my visit, however, it felt somewhat lacking in the former and sparse on the promised local game, though the season and appalling weather may have been to blame.

For me, the grilled octopus bouillabaisse on the winter’s menu smacked more of Provence than Hawnby, unless the eight-armed mollusc came from the Yorkshire coast, as I hear they’ve been making their presence felt recently.

We started with a curried parsnip soup, a potted shrimp crumpet with leeks, passing over a beetroot with goat’s cheese and a radicchio salad, and a buttermilk-fried pheasant with cranberry chipotle.

Though each dish was tempting, hot soup on a filthy night will always win with me, and this one did perfectly - warming, silky, and with the precise level of spiciness.

The leek dish also showed great promise; the soft crumpet was adorned with tiny pink potted shrimp and a handsome pile of leeks in a creamy, broth-like sauce, though the husband said he would have liked more shrimp.

We tucked into both dishes with relish and, to be frank, had forgotten we were the only diners at that point.

For mains, I moved on from the octopus and the ricotta gnocchi with wild mushrooms, however tempting it sounded.

I dove instead into an earthy, nourishing bowl of Toulouse sausage with lentils, Cavolo Nero, grape mustard, and celeriac remoulade.

Classic cooking, though the Tuscans may raise an eyebrow at Cavolo in a French-inspired dish though I didn’t care; it was excellent.

The dish was filling, and I couldn’t finish all the fat, spicy sausages - so they went home with me and made an appearance in a pasta dish the next day.

I might have declared my main the hit of the night, but it was the burger that stole that title.

A brioche bun loaded with bone marrow onions, tomato, a thick, impeccably cooked tender short-rib burger, and a heap of Ogleshield cheese - a nutty, Raclette-inspired cheese which melted beautifully over the meat - made it quite the triumph from across the table, much to his delight.

Pudding was the only disappointment.

Following the theme of weatherproofing ourselves for the drive home, we passed on a plum sorbet, Affogato, chocolate orange crèmeux, and even a Tiramisu, choosing, obviously, the treacle sponge with Calvados custard and stem ginger ice cream.

The sponge was a little dry, and the custard on the point of splitting, possibly due to a heavy dose of alcohol. The ice cream, though, was first-rate.

I cannot speak to the atmosphere on the night of our visit, but we certainly had a good time and were more than happy that we battled through the scary roads and didn’t turn back.

Service was spot on - though they didn’t have much to do except look after us - and they did that well, even suggesting a safer route home, which we took.

The Owl is in a glorious setting for that alone; it’s worth a trip. It’s a lovely building, and though I’ve never stayed there or seen the bedrooms, I can only imagine they are equally charming.

Will has started well, given the big shoes he had to fill. If he fulfils his promise of more traditional pub fare for those who’ve hiked up and down the dale and are expecting it and he delivers on local game, he’s on a winner.

Welcome 5/5

Food 4/5

Atmosphere 4/5

Prices 4/5

The Owl Hawnby, Hill Top, Hawnby, York, YO62 5QS Tel: 01439 330180

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice