The Penny Bun review: Askwith inn gives plenty of reasons to be cheerful

Amanda Wragg has always flown the flag for the traditional pub which is enduring some tough times but The Penny Bun in Askwith has given her plenty of reasons to be cheerful.

Pubs are essential to my well-being. I would say that, as the daughter of a landlord and lady. I’m rarely happier than when I’m heading for the Big 6 in Halifax, The Laurel or Dolphin in Robin Hoods Bay or the Parkers Arms in Newton in Bowland. They’re stitched into the fabric of my life, for me and millions of other Boomers, an integral part of our history, community and culture. I say Boomers because up until recently we couldn’t rely on Generation Z to keep pubs open because they eschewed drinking, but I’ve just read that they’ve started again. Hooray.

Tom Kerridge has been on, telling us that 21 venues are closing every week (pubs, restaurants, chippies) and he’s calling for a cut in VAT for the hospitality industry from Andy Burnham, who reckons he has it in his sights.

In the light of all this news, I’m very pleased to hear that The Penny Bun in Askwith has just been awarded the prestigious title of AA Inn of the Year for England. The award combines ‘high-quality overnight accommodation with exceptional pub food and drink. It recognizes warm hospitality and strong local character’. Well done Penny Bun. I can’t vouch for the comfort of the beds because I haven’t overnighted, but I can tell you about the grub.

Pulled Pork Flatbread at The Penny Bun, West Ln, Askwith, Otley. Picture: Simon Hulme.placeholder image
Pulled Pork Flatbread at The Penny Bun, West Ln, Askwith, Otley. Picture: Simon Hulme.

First though, let me tell you about arriving, for no other reason than it’s a joy. Tyres crunch on gravel to the car park and at the back of the pub there’s a handsome Grand Designs-type terrace for drinks and views with just the sound of the birds for company on a still, warm summer evening.

We take a cocktail (an Old Fashioned for me, a pint of ‘superbly-kept’ Landlord for himself) joining a couple with a cute dog eating their dinner al fresco, a mum and dad with a relatively well-behaved two-year-old and a stylish older couple enjoying Espresso Martinis and sporting immaculate linen (how do people do that? Two minutes of wear and I’m a crumpled mess).

Inside it’s a hushed, muted palette, with walls and ceiling finished in natural clay plaster, unfussy but sophisticated. It’s stripped back and quietly moody, with beautiful, old flagged floors. Any thoughts of austerity lift with a warm, cheery welcome. When I went for lunch a couple of years ago, a week after they’d opened, my chum thought it a bit gloomy but I find it restful. It’s a matter of taste. Either way it’s a stylish, contemporary look, and more’s to the point it’s sustainable, being part of the innovative Denton Reserve, which is a 2,500-acre nature regeneration project.

But you want to know about the food, right? It’s a shortish menu but with interesting choices, and I was drawn to all of it: four starters including Caesar salad with smoked garlic dressing, marinated anchovies and Yorkshire Pecorino, and a smoked salmon salad with lemon dressing and a nasturtium potato salad. It was a close-run thing but Isle of Wight tomatoes won – and it’s summer on a plate. Roasted and piled on homemade focaccia with a sharp pesto, all softened by gorgeous burrata cream topped with a super-light tempura courgette flower. Flatbreads are having a moment and I love them, so it was pulled Denton Tamworth pork, preserved wild garlic with salsa verde: a lovely plate of food, all the flavours too.

Honey Tart. Picture: Simon Hulme.placeholder image
Honey Tart. Picture: Simon Hulme.

Seven mains include pan roast corn fed chicken, French peas & braised lettuce – a classic dish I’ll be having next time, a fresh seafood pasta with trout, clams, scallops and monk’s beard in a creamy wine sauce, a posh burger (White Park steak, taleggio and bacon jam) and a risotto. I absolutely cannot say no to a fresh pasta dish with ragu – but with the added bonus of the sauce made with Denton Red Deer – are you kidding me? Add Yorkshire nduja and courgettes: fabulous. Cooked for the requisite number of days it was melt in the mouth, with a cheeky kick from the nduja, qualifying as one of the best I’ve had. Hand made ricotta gnocchi is slightly less successful – tasty enough with lots of sage, just a bit over generous with the brown butter, but the Yorkshire ricotta and earthy beets add a good note.

Head Chef is Tim Kitchen, and he’s got the benefit of estate-reared meats and the revival of the historic walled garden to put into practise the restaurant's ‘field to fork’ approach. Originally from Surrey, he’s a self-taught chef, honing his skills at worldwide restaurant group D&D London. He was part of the opening team for Crafthouse and Angelica in Leeds, and rose through the ranks. I notice he’s a big fan of terroir (using everything around you), so it’s lucky for him (and us) that the estate is literally on the doorstep and forms the core of his cooking.

It’s worth mentioning that despite the cool sophistication of the place the atmosphere in the room is really lovely; great music, and the buzz of people having a good time.

Out of the four desserts, the honey tart with honey Chantilly with Annabelle’s strawberries draws me in and it’s a very lovely thing – exactly the right (room) temperature. There’s also a STP of course and tiramisu.

Handmade Gnocchi Sage Butter.placeholder image
Handmade Gnocchi Sage Butter.

In a few weeks’ time they prepare to compete for the overall title (England, Scotland and Wales) at an awards ceremony in London. This accolade highlights the inn’s commitment to quality and exceptional hospitality. If the welcome, food and service is anything to go by, they’re a shoo-in and I’ll be having a fiver on them.

As for the bedrooms? Judging by the photos, they’re done out in the same uncluttered, minimalist fashion as the rest of the place, so not a whiff of chintz. If this is the future of pubs, we’re in safe hands.

Ratings:

Welcome – 5/5

Isle of Wight Tomatoes, Burrata Cream, Deep Fried Courgette Flower. Picture: Simon Hulme.placeholder image
Isle of Wight Tomatoes, Burrata Cream, Deep Fried Courgette Flower. Picture: Simon Hulme.

Food – 5/5

Atmosphere – 5/5

Prices – 5/5

Dinner for two, three courses with cocktails and wine £181

The Penny Bun, West Lane, Askwith, Otley LS21 2JQ

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice