Harrogate man who left puppy Ivy with 'unfathomable' injuries given suspended sentence and lifetime animal ban

A Harrogate man who left a puppy with “unfathomable” injuries, leading to her to be euthanised, has been given a suspended sentence and lifetime animal ban.

American bulldog, Ivy, suffered three broken legs and a jaw after her owner Kyle Dorling attacked the six-month-old puppy over several months.

Between December 2022 and March 2023, Dorling, 27 now of Harwood Road in Harrogate, caused the puppy to suffer three broken legs and a fractured jaw, along with multiple other injuries.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Recorder David Gordon described the case as a “prolonged and serious infliction of cruelty”, and said six-month-old Ivy, who had to be euthanised as a result of her injuries, had suffered a “high level of pain and suffering”’

American bulldog, Ivy, suffered three broken legs and a jaw after her owner Kyle Dorling attacked the six-month-old puppy over several months.American bulldog, Ivy, suffered three broken legs and a jaw after her owner Kyle Dorling attacked the six-month-old puppy over several months.
American bulldog, Ivy, suffered three broken legs and a jaw after her owner Kyle Dorling attacked the six-month-old puppy over several months.

The court heard that a member of the public had spotted the puppy in the grounds of a block of flats at Woodland Road in the Norton Lees area of Sheffield on 25 March 2023.

She noticed the young dog was skinny and couldn't walk properly and kept lifting her left paw.

There was scarring on her mouth, which looked like it had been tied shut, and the pads on her feet were bloody and raw.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Ivy was taken by the finder to the local authority’s dog warden service where she was cared for and seen by a vet.

The decision was then made to put her to sleep to prevent further suffering.The decision was then made to put her to sleep to prevent further suffering.
The decision was then made to put her to sleep to prevent further suffering.

Because of the suspicious nature of her injuries she was then collected by the RSPCA and an investigation by the animal welfare charity began.

The court heard that Dorling was identified as Ivy’s owner by her microchip and lived in Woodland Road, where she was found.

RSPCA Inspector Jennie Ronksley was told that he had offered the dog to someone else, but they’d said no, and he had then apparently dumped her on the landing and left.

Dorling was traced to East Sussex by the RSPCA.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
There was scarring on her mouth, which looked like it had been tied shut, and the pads on her feet were bloody and raw.There was scarring on her mouth, which looked like it had been tied shut, and the pads on her feet were bloody and raw.
There was scarring on her mouth, which looked like it had been tied shut, and the pads on her feet were bloody and raw.

In a phone call with Inspector Ronksley he said that Ivy had gone missing and that he had reported it on a lost and found site.

He said he used to crate her while he was at work and that she had a ‘bad leg’ from when she tried to get out of it.

He was later interviewed in East Sussex and denied having ever intentionally harmed Ivy, saying he wasn’t aware she had broken bones and thought they were minor injuries.

The court was told that Dorling had taken Ivy to a vet on January 25, 2023 as she wasn’t bearing weight on her right back leg.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

As he was eligible for subsidised treatment, he was told to book radiographs for her at the PDSA but failed to attend the appointment.

Over three weeks later he took Ivy in with similar symptoms, although she now also had swelling on her bottom jaw.

Dorling was told to bring in a urine sample for her as soon as possible so vets could start to investigate what might be wrong, but they never saw him again.

In her written evidence, the vet who examined Ivy on March 30, on behalf of the RSPCA, said she was underweight and unable to walk normally.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“There was a marked angular limb deformity on her right front leg and she was completely non-weight bearing on her right back leg,” the vet added.

“She also had abrasions on multiple pads on all four feet, which were indicative of suspected trauma.”

X-rays revealed historic fractures of Ivy’s jaw, both front legs, left back leg and cheekbone.

The court was told there was no history of her having been involved in any accident that could have accounted for her injuries and that Dorling was circumstantially implicated in having physically abused her.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Given how the fractures had healed, the vet said Ivy’s prognosis was ‘grave’ and ‘irreparable’.

Her right back leg would need to be completely amputated and the changes to her right front leg were so severe that she would never be able to have good enough mobility - if any - especially for a growing, large breed dog.

The decision was then made to put her to sleep to prevent further suffering.

In her evidence to the court, the vet said: “As veterinary surgeons we are sadly accustomed to seeing fractures and trauma on a regular basis.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“However, what is so utterly devastating in this case is that Ivy had been left with multiple fractures across their body for weeks with very minimal, if any, treatment.

“The pain that Ivy would have been in with one, let alone five, fractures is unfathomable. What is most upsetting is that an owner would leave their own pet in such an excruciatingly painful state without seeking emergency veterinary care other than sporadically over a period of a few months.

“The owner would have known that Ivy was suffering without seeking thorough and continued veterinary care. He also failed to bring her back for appointments and further work.

“What is also concerning is the markings over the muzzle that indicate forceful restraint with a linear object so tight there had been chronic changes in the skin and fur. The owner claimed this was due to her rubbing her nose on the bars of her crate which is not at all plausible or possible.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

At a sentencing hearing at Sheffield Crown Court on Wednesday (Jan 8), Dorling was given an 18 month custodial sentence, suspended for two years, and disqualified from keeping animals for an indefinite period.

Dorling, who will not be able to contest his ban for ten years, was also given a three month electronic curfew between 8pm and 8am and up to 20 Rehabilitation Activity Requirement Days and ordered to pay £400 in costs and a victim surcharge of £154.

In mitigation the court was told he had experienced a difficult upbringing and had poor mental health which had impacted on his thinking and behaviour and made it difficult for him to control his temper.

His mental health was still an issue, but he had demonstrated remorse for his actions, had no previous convictions and had been assessed as being capable of rehabilitation within the community.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
©National World Publishing Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice