A robust attitude needs to be taken by the Government on bank closures - Andrew Vine

An unwelcome milestone was passed a couple of years ago in my corner of Yorkshire when the last local bank branch closed. For me, the consequence of that meant a 10-minute walk was replaced by a 10-mile round trip to the nearest remaining branch if I need to carry out a transaction in person.

Fortunately, I can drive there or catch a bus, so it’s straightforward even if it is inconvenient and costs me either £5 in parking or the same amount in fares.

But for an elderly person who does not drive, or is less mobile than they would like and struggles with public transport, that journey to do their banking is a daunting prospect that represents the callous abandonment of a section of society by the companies we have no choice but to depend on to keep our money safe.

Older people in a couple of Yorkshire towns are soon to face the same problem, when the Santander branches in Northallerton and Pontefract close. They join an ever-lengthening list of places large and small in our county where an open bank is a rarity or even anything more than a memory.

A Santander branch. PIC: Mike Egerton/PA Wireplaceholder image
A Santander branch. PIC: Mike Egerton/PA Wire

The branches are among 44 being shut nationally by Santander, putting 291 jobs at risk, and come on top of plans announced last year to close 95 – or a quarter – of its branches which employed 750 people.

It is not only Santander which is abandoning communities. By March, Lloyds will have shut 100 branches in a closure programme that began last year.

Banks shutting, and people being left with long journeys in order to manage their money have become one of the most depressingly familiar news stories in recent years as the branch network has been torn to shreds.

And each of those stories brings with it the same utterly disingenuous rationale for axing face-to-face banking. Transactions have all moved online, say the banks, without acknowledging that they have forced this to happen by closing branches and making it increasingly difficult to do business in person.

The repeated assertion that there is falling demand for counter services does not stand scrutiny.

The Nationwide building society is currently running an advertising campaign that is focussed on its branch network. Over the past year, the number of people using those branches has increased.

The attitude of the banks towards both their customers and staff is one of the most hard-faced to be found anywhere in the corporate world.

Customers are effectively coerced into using often unreliable online services and couldn’t-care-less call centres while staff numbers are ruthlessly pruned in order to cut costs.

Even when the banks grudgingly retain a presence in city centres, they push their customers to go online. A counter service will have one or two cashiers at most, while staff are deployed to advise people queuing that they could probably make their transactions via the website or app.

These hugely profitable institutions have simply ignored the concerns expressed by successive governments about closing banks.

They have also demonstrated their heartlessness towards vulnerable members of society by taking absolutely no notice of charities campaigning for older people, which have protested against the closures.

The welcome development of “banking hubs” which are run by Post Office staff has helped to plug some of the gaps in face-to-face services, and several have opened in Yorkshire towns in recent years, among them Otley, Wetherby and Knaresborough.

But openings of these hubs are not keeping pace with branch closures. The current round certainly will not be the last and yet more places in Yorkshire will become banking deserts.

The government ought to be far more robust in its attitude towards bank closures than it has been. Ministers expressing concern is not enough.

Even if they lack powers to compel the banks to keep branches open, they should certainly be calling in directors and pressuring them to halt closures. At the same time, the government needs to do everything possible to accelerate the opening of more banking hubs.

And ministers should have in mind there are sound political reasons for saving face-to-face banking. Last week, research by Southampton University found increasing levels of dissatisfaction among the public at the decline of high streets.

The loss of banks is an important factor in shopping streets feeling run-down because the customers they once had are lost to retailers.

People surveyed felt that those in power didn’t care, and that could translate into votes against Labour, which means saving banks might just save the skins of quite a few MPs at the next election.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice