A year on, Kemi Badenoch and the Tories look all at sea with Reform now the unofficial opposition - Ismail Mulla

So last weekend, Kemi Badenoch marked one year as leader of the Tory party. A cause for celebration, usually. And given the abyss that the Tories had sunk into at the previous general election, you’d think that the only way was up.

However, Badenoch has managed to steer the submarine further into the abyss. Where even the odd ray of light is only fleeting. It really is an astounding feat.

She became leader after another interminably long Tory party leadership contest, where instead of talking to the public, the candidates once again fought to see who could dance to the tune of the membership. A membership that itself is at war with each other.

Since then the leader of the Tory party has started a new policy platform that suspiciously has the air of the recent platforms that the Tories claimed to stand on. Bandenoch said she was “rebuilding” the Conservative party. Unfortunately for her, the foundations to this rebuild already look shaky.

Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch gives a speech during a rally. PIC: James Manning/PA Wireplaceholder image
Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch gives a speech during a rally. PIC: James Manning/PA Wire

That is not to say that the Tories have not been able to lay a glove on the Government as the official Opposition. Winter fuel payments, the family farms tax and fumbling of welfare cuts is just some of the ammunition that Sir Keir Starmer’s hapless Government has provided to the Opposition.

Few would argue that was because of adroit leadership on Badenoch’s part, rather Starmer’s party waltzing into the ring, guard down and leading with its chin. It was asking to be clobbered.

The real problem for Badenoch is the fact that the opposition on the streets is now seen as Nigel Farage and his upstarts from Reform UK. No matter how hard Badenoch and the Tories try to out-Reform them, they continue to take the headlines and more importantly dominate the opinion polls.

It’s created a problem for Labour but it could prove to be an even bigger problem for the Tories and that is that it could end up permanently lost in the political abyss. On the current trajectory, they could end up at best a Lib Dem styled proposition that has its audience but won’t be taken seriously by the wider majority. At worst, it could end up having to fold into Reform.

Now that may still seem extreme. How could a party nearly two centuries old, and origins going back even further, just disappear? But that’s what making the same mistakes that got you into the mess that you're in usually leads to.

Badenoch says: “I’ve spent this year giving the country a serious alternative to Labour’s weakness: a plan for a stronger economy and stronger borders.

“The Conservatives have set out detailed, costed policies to cut waste, lower taxes, control immigration and reward work. We’ve shown how to fix welfare, stop the boats, cut energy bills and make work pay again.”

The earlier point that I laid out is underlined by the latest polling from YouGov, which makes a mockery of Badenoch’s insistence that voters view the Tories as a credible alternative to the Labour Government.

The poll suggests voters are unconvinced by Badenoch: 12 per cent believe she is a prime minister in waiting, while 62 per cent do not.

However, it is a different story amongst Conservative members, with 54 per cent believing that she is doing a good job as party leader, while 24 per cent say she has done a bad job.

And more worrying for Badenoch, pollsters have also suggested the Tories are less popular than the Lib Dems, as Reform continues to lead with the public.

The reality is that Badenoch needs to make the Tories distinguishable from Reform, fast. At the moment, all she has got to offer is that her party is more financially prudent.

While the majority of membership may be happy with Badenoch, it is clear that the policy platform that she is laying down is drawing scorn from some very important voices in the Labour party.

Former prime minister Boris Johnson, who remains popular amongst many Conservatives, took aim at the party’s current policy of repealing the Climate Change Act and abandoning the commitment to reach net zero by 2050.

Johnson says the Conservatives cannot win the next election by “bashing the green agenda”. He isn’t alone, Theresa May and Sir John Major have also voiced their concern.

Pledging to leave the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) is another issue that is divisive with a recent poll suggesting that it may not even play that well with the public.

The next election may seem a long way away but time is running out for Badenoch’s vessel.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice