Carers deserve better than a system that punishes them - Anna Dixon

This year will mark exactly half a century since Carer’s Allowance was first introduced. When it was created in 1976, it was the first time the state formally recognised the enormous sacrifices unpaid carers make.

And while the world has changed dramatically since Harold Wilson’s heyday, the essential role that carers play in holding families, and public services together certainly has not. Far too often, though, they do so while being overlooked, undervalued and pushed into poverty.

There are an estimated 5.8 million unpaid carers across the UK, who provide services worth a colossal £184bn every year - that is more than a third higher than the entire NHS budget for England in 2025/26. Yet, despite this frankly staggering economic contribution, almost 1.2 million carers are living in poverty right now, with one in ten in deep poverty.

Research conducted by Carers UK found that around half of carers had to cut back on basic essentials last year. Many find themselves in a position where they have to reduce their working hours or leave their employment entirely, harming their future career prospects and potentially jeopardising their financial stability. This is such a common situation that an estimated 600 people each day leave the workforce to care for a loved one, resulting in £37bn in lost productivity for the economy every year.

The hands of an elderly woman. PIC: Yui Mok/PA Wireplaceholder image
The hands of an elderly woman. PIC: Yui Mok/PA Wire

This is the backdrop to which the Carer’s Allowance Overpayment Scandal unfolded, which left thousands of carers who were already close to breaking point, facing astronomical debts they had never knowingly incurred. Over several years, largely due to system errors and flawed, confusing guidance, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) mistakenly punished thousands of carers who unintentionally exceeded strict earnings rules.

The Sayce Review, published this month, was unequivocal in its findings that these overpayments resulted from systemic failures, not from the carers themselves, who were often left with unclear guidance and tight rules that were at times near impossible to follow.

For so many, the consequences have been utterly devastating. Across the country, carers found themselves racking up thousands of pounds in debt, often with barely an explanation of how or why. Instead of being treated with dignity and respect for their selfless act of love, the state treated them as potential fraudsters, and many were issued civil penalties.

The Sayce Review, commissioned by this current Labour Government, is an effort to right some of these awful wrongs. I am glad that the government has accepted the majority of the report's recommendations, and has started to assess some 200,000 cases with a view to repaying or cancelling them, and has set aside £75m to implement this. Sayce also calls for a full reassessment of cases and for short-term measures to address the ‘cliff edge’ in the earnings limit. Currently, earning even a penny over the threshold means losing the entire weekly allowance of £83.30. The review makes clear that while this cliff edge does not cause overpayments, it dramatically worsens their impact.

However, even if every recommendation is implemented, the key issue of the level of Carer’s Allowance still remains. At £80.30, it is the lowest benefit of its kind, with over two-thirds of those who receive it living in poverty.

With the anniversary of the Allowance, we have an opportunity, and in my view a moral obligation, to do better. Carers deserve a system that recognises the enormous contribution that they make and allows them to live with dignity and financial security. Increasing the level of Carer’s Allowance would be a powerful step towards that goal.

Carers give so much. It’s time we gave something back.

Anna Dixon is the Labour MP for Shipley and chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Carers.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice