Data centres being dumped in Yorkshire won’t create good jobs - Andy Brown

It all sounds so promising. Britain will attract the next generation of technology into specially established enterprise zones and the economy will get back to growth on the back of a boom in AI sited right here in the north.

That formed a big part of the last government’s plan and it is one of those rare ambitions which has survived political change and been enthusiastically adopted by the new lot.

Bringing back more manufacturing jobs to Britain would be a very good thing that would help rebalance our economy away from an over reliance on financial services.

Unfortunately talking about attracting good quality jobs into a lightly regulated enterprise zone is a lot easier than delivering and not all of the organisations that wish to take advantage of lighter regulations, tax breaks and easier planning rules are genuinely interested in bringing prosperity to neglected regions.

A person's hand pressing keys of a laptop keyboard. PIC: Dominic Lipinski/PA Wireplaceholder image
A person's hand pressing keys of a laptop keyboard. PIC: Dominic Lipinski/PA Wire

Whisper it but some less scrupulous businesses talk a good game but are actually only interested in cheap land and weak controls over how they treat their employees and the local environment. Others gobble up a lot of land and energy but do little of value for the local community and may actually damage the British economy.

Most artificial intelligence data centres should be top of the list of unwelcome arrivals.

Nothing is manufactured in a data centre. What they consist of are bank after bank of computers sifting through enormous quantities of data and trying to take from it the information its designers have decided is useful.

Running those machines doesn’t require much in the way of skilled labour. They can be programmed from anywhere in the world. The only kinds of jobs that need to be done locally are cleaning, maintenance and security. Relative to the size of the warehouses that means there are desperately few new jobs and no reason to believe that siting thousands of computers will create any kind of technology boom in the locality.

What is created is a lot of heat. Computers get very hot and long lines of them working flat out all day get even hotter. That requires immense amounts of water to cool the machines.

Yorkshire does, of course, have its fair share of rain. It also has more than its fair share of neglected water infrastructure as a result of decades of privatised companies focusing on money instead of water infrastructure. We can ill afford to house companies that need to extract a lot of water all year round if we are going to have more dry summers.

These AI centres take advantage of the expensive infrastructure that supplies them and us with water but make no significant contribution towards its improvement. They create a risk of more hose pipe bans. Local farmers could be asked to stop irrigating crops so that those who only farm data can send profits to overseas investors.

Similar pressures occur on our electricity grid. Data centres use astonishing quantities of energy and that poses a serious threat to our supply infrastructure and creates unwelcome extra pressure on the challenge of powering our nation.

What we get when a new AI data centre arrives in Britain is a drain on our energy reliability, a drain on our water resources, and few jobs of any quality. Giving over our scarce assets of suitable land for development to such businesses is more likely to restrict growth by adding to costs of energy and water than promoting it.

Governments in a number of countries are becoming increasingly cautious about the benefits of this kind of business activity. Ours is allowing such developers to ride roughshod over planning laws and granting them concessions on national insurance payments, land costs and pollution controls.

There are, of course, great opportunities in Yorkshire to foster high quality businesses and generate significant numbers of jobs for the future. Business parks and enterprise spin offs from our great network of Universities and Colleges are at the heart of those opportunities.

Letting a hedge fund dump a load of computers in a field and laugh at our naivety is not the same thing as investing in a new science park in a former industrial heartland.

What is even worse about some of these data centres is that they are burning power and consuming water without doing anything useful. Some of those powerful computers are devoted to doing nothing other than ‘mining’ bitcoin.

It is hard to state how damaging an activity that is. Effectively it involves burning fossil fuels to try and create artificial money which will enable criminals and tax dodgers to hide their assets. Do we really want to provide tax breaks to attract that kind of activity?

When we left the EU we were promised that regional development policy would become much more flexible and effective whilst important controls over working conditions and environmental standards would remain in place. The creation of so called freeports cuts directly against those promises.

Andy Brown is the Green Party Councillor for Aire Valley.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice