How can anyone justify the earnings of the likes of the Yorkshire Water boss Nicola Shaw? - David Behrens
Last Tuesday, with the year not a week old, the chief executive’s earnings at an average large company overtook those of an ordinary worker for the whole of 2026. Just take a moment to let that sink in: less than six days for the boss to earn what you or I might do in a year. That being the case, you do wonder why these firms don’t get better people for their money.
Let’s take a couple of examples of hopeless head honchos at companies where the brain drain begins in the boardroom…
This week Paul Patterson, wretched European boss of the computer giant Fujitsu, admitted to MPs that he had set aside not a single penny to compensate the hundreds of subpostmasters wrongly convicted of fraud because his lousy software couldn’t add up their accounts.
The Government, whose officials handed Fujitsu the Post Office Horizon IT contract and many others of incalculable value, has budgeted £1.8bn of public money to help right the wrongs the firm has wrought – but Patterson lamely said it had so far contributed nothing to the pot because “we don’t know the exact number that should be”.


What d’you mean, you don’t know, mate? You run a computer company: isn’t that what computers are for?
Fujitsu has had no problem calculating what it should pay its executives: they have pocketed more than £26m since the Post Office contract began. One manager alone was handed a £2.6m ‘loss of office’ payment when he left at the height of the scandal. It was a figure so unbelievable they must have used Horizon to work it out.
Meanwhile, the victims of one of the biggest miscarriages of justice in history have had to listen to Patterson talk of a “moral contribution” – and you don’t need a computer to calculate what that will be worth.
But he is not alone in his tone deafness to public opinion about the mismatch between executives’ salaries and their competence. It’s a discrepancy that is nowhere more obvious than here in Yorkshire.
Nicola Shaw has salted away £3m over two years for heading up the region’s most despised and worst-managed utility, Yorkshire Water. Close to half of that amount came in the form of under-the-counter bonuses from the parent company in Jersey, which has no requirement to declare them to the regulator. It was an arrangement as murky as all the sewage her firm pumps into our waterways.
A great deal of bad press was generated by this revelation last summer and perhaps as a result, Ms Shaw was sent out on a charm offensive just before Christmas.
A ‘meet the people’ event which was held remotely on Zoom so that no-one really met anyone, saw her attempt to blame the firm’s failings on the fact that the public’s expectations were too high. “People don’t expect any kind of interruption and they don’t expect any kind of discharge of sewage,” she complained.
In other words, when something goes wrong it’s our fault for expecting her to do her job.
There was more. Water shortages and sewage discharges had been “driven off a desire to keep bills as low as possible”, said the woman who is now increasing them by 29 per cent.
You don’t need a Post Office computer to do the maths here: it is 42 years since a reservoir was last built in Yorkshire – it was at Grimwith in the southern Dales – and since then the county’s population has risen by half a million. But handling the extra demand has taken second place to the thirst for profits.
It is often argued – not least by Ms Shaw last month when she subjected herself to a BBC interrogation by, er, the weatherman Paul Hudson – that executives don’t set their own salaries but are paid the going rate.
However, utilities like Yorkshire Water, with a guaranteed income and no competition, cannot be compared to wholly commercial entities like Marks and Spencer, whose CEO will likely see his £7m salary slashed in the wake of the costly cyber-attack he presided over last year.
Ms Shaw, on the other hand, is protected by a culture of complacency that can be traced all the way back to Cedric Brown, the original fat cat whose salary for running British Gas went up 900 per cent in the decade after privatisation and who made his firm a byword for profligacy and excess. He eventually retired with an annual pension of close to £500,000 at today’s rates
Is Nicola Shaw any more credible than him? Try asking her staff: their average salary is a little over £30,000 and they’re the ones who roll up their sleeves and get their hands dirty, often literally, while she swans around on charm offensives she has only half mastered: no charm, just a lot of offensiveness.
