Mandelson’s ill-fated appointment highlights Labour’s ‘women problem’ - Jayne Dowle

There has always been a distinct whiff of ‘boys’ club’ mentality in Downing Street, whoever the Prime Minister of the day happens to be. Who can forget the shameful antics, the parties and the entitled behaviour of staffers during the pandemic under Boris Johnson?

Women might have been involved, but they would never, ever have set such a culture in motion.

However, the furore over Peter Mandelson’s association with convicted paedophile Jeffery Epstein has put the matter of Labour’s ‘women problem’ front and centre.

Labour MP Emily Darlington, a campaigner for equality for women in Parliament, told the website PoliticsHome that the Epstein case had revealed “a culture around the rich and powerful men that get protected”, adding, “the closed men's spaces in politics continue”.

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer takes part in a business roundtable. PIC: Brian Lawless/PA Wireplaceholder image
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer takes part in a business roundtable. PIC: Brian Lawless/PA Wire

“It controls who is promoted, who is put in place, and who has power within those networks. We are seeing those two scenarios, both of those things coming together.”

It turns out that Starmer, whose public dramatis persona takes moral righteousness as its compass, knew about Mandelson’s links to Epstein when he appointed the former Labour cabinet minister to the pivotal role of US ambassador. This is a position Mandelson has now been forced to vacate, but not before asking for a compensation sum north of £500,000.

In the end Mandelson got £75,000 and continues to be investigated by police over allegations of misconduct in public office.

However many women Starmer appoints to prominent positions, there’s a murky undercurrent undermining public trust in his motivations.

He might point to the recent appointment of Dame Antonia Romeo as the new Cabinet Secretary and head of the UK Civil Service as evidence he has learned from his mistakes and is now taking women seriously.

If a woman – or women, indeed – had been involved in the ratification of Mandelson it’s an absolute certainty that they would have asked more questions, probed deeper into the links, and this whole sorry mess, which has embarrassed the UK and made relations with the US at such a crucial time even trickier, would never have been allowed to unfold.

Starmer has now admitted that he “made a mistake, and it’s me that makes the apology to the victims of Epstein, and I do that.”

However, there is also the issue of Matthew Doyle, elevated to a life peerage despite the former Downing Street communications chief losing the Labour whip over his past campaigning for a councillor later convicted of child sex offences.

Female Cabinet ministers are right to be livid. Around a month ago, Lisa Nandy, Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, called out the “boys’ club” publicly, complaining that “some of the briefings have absolutely been dripping with misogyny”.

Women in the current government are seemingly used like chess pieces, interchangeable and moved around on a board to achieve a positive gloss. Do you remember back in September, when former deputy PM and deputy party leader Angela Rayner was forced to resign over her tax affairs?

The cry went up for a working class Northern woman to replace her, as if Rayner’s background and sex simply ticked a box; it’s seriously unacceptable to reduce anyone, man or woman, to such a cipher.

At the 2024 General Election, Labour saw 190 female MPs returned to the House of Commons, the highest number ever. Yet as with many other things, Starmer appears to have squandered this advantage.

Some of us might have expected Labour, the party of ‘equality’, to do better. Then again some of us know from rueful personal experience that there’s a certain DNA strand running through (some) Labour men that we might call ‘dinosaur’.

Is it any accident that the Conservatives have fielded three female Prime Ministers to date and Labour has never appointed a woman leader? This from a political party which historically, has always elected more women MPs than any other.

Whilst Starmer attempts to steer a steady course through the crisis of the war on Iran, the unsavoury accusations that No 10 contains a cabal of men who don’t want women in the room won’t go away

Labour’s parity problem is all the more galling because this government has made it a mission to halve violence against women and girls (VAWG) within a decade.

However, if it can’t treat senior women in politics seriously and with respect, how can we trust that this policy comes from the right place?

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice