PM on the back foot after Mandelson arrest and by-election defeat would only ramp up pressure
The Prime Minister was already under pressure before the Mandelson scandal erupted last year with Labour resembling a rudderless vessel performing U-turn after U-turn.
But the arrest of Lord Peter Mandelson this week has left Sir Keir Starmer in an incredibly difficult position. After various policy failures, ranging from welfare reforms to Inheritance Tax (IHT) changes, the PM’s judgement has also been called into question.
The arrest of Mandelson means that the PM can’t brush this off as Westminster tittle tattle. While Sir Keir has changed advisers in the wake of the Mandelson scandal, the public won’t be convinced unless there’s a major change in direction by this Government. As Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch says, the PM is “distracted by Labour scandal after Labour scandal”.
Applying the Nolan Principles of public life to this scandal, you get a full house of failure.


The responsibility ultimately lies with the Prime Minister. The public will take a dim view of Sir Keir blaming advice or a lack of it for what was obviously a mistake. It was not long ago that trust in the then PM Boris Johnson collapsed as he evaded responsibility.
With voters going to the polls in the Gorton and Denton byelection today, the pressure will only increase on the PM should Labour lose the seat. While the PM is likely to be safe regardless in the interim, Sir Keir would be severely weakened heading into the summer.
It would be another crisis of the PM’s own making. The role that Sir Keir played in blocking Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham from standing in the by-election will come to the fore. The reality is that Burnham’s popularity would have made the going much easier for Labour in Gorton and Denton.
