Rising number of Neets is not down to fecklessness amongst young people - Andy Brown

It takes some doing. In a country with an aging population over one million young people are without work and not training. Whilst the birth rate has dropped to an alarmingly low 1.39 per woman the number of young people not in education employment now stands at 1,012,000.

There are many plausible explanations for this. An increase in the fecklessness of young people is not one of them.

Unemployment almost never rises or falls because of changing social attitudes. It goes up when there are fewer jobs available than people looking for them and down when the equation is reversed. There is a shortage of jobs and training opportunities not a sudden change in the willingness to work of an entire generation.

The worst rise in unemployment since the war took place in the 1970s when the then Prime Minister presided over the biggest loss of traditional manufacturing jobs in Britain and pushed unemployment up. By 1982 it reached three million.

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre) and Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden (left) meet apprentices. PIC: Simon Jones/The Sun/PA Wireplaceholder image
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre) and Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden (left) meet apprentices. PIC: Simon Jones/The Sun/PA Wire

Entire northern communities were damaged as Margaret Thatcher enthusiastically told us we had to let markets decide what happened and she exported manufacturing jobs. Not everyone who was thrown out of work was able to take up expanding opportunities in fields such as financial management.

Those who complained were delivered a lecture by Norman Tebitt about the importance of getting on a bike and riding round asking for work.

That strategy might work for one individual. It can never fix the overall absence of available jobs. It may be true that the most energetic job seekers will land the available jobs but it is also true that if there are more people seeking jobs than opportunities on offer then the bulk of people are doomed to fail.

Right now every week that a hopeful new entrant to the job market remains out of work the harder it gets to obtain an opportunity. Demoralisation and bouts of depression set in for some young people. Others find a dangerous outlet in drug dealing and gang culture. Even those who hold it together and eventually get work are known to end up with lower overall career earnings on average than those who are fortunate enough to come onto the market when there are plenty of jobs.

Normally the best advice that can be given to anyone struggling to find an opportunity is to learn a higher level of skills. Yet this time round that may not work. In the era of artificial intelligence companies that used to offer entry level professional jobs don’t want new recruits.

AI is taking opportunities in law firms, accountancy firms, and some forms of IT. There is absolutely no sign of it taking jobs in plumbing.

From the point of view of the individual young person this means that it is likely to become steadily better value to invest time and money on doing an apprenticeship than it is to learn great chunks of legal case law when a machine can scan data, extract the main points and prepare a letter on behalf of a client in seconds.

This often leads to cries of ‘bring back apprenticeships’. The truth is they never went away. They just changed in nature and got under-valued by a series of different governments, by school’s plugging the sixth form as the favoured route and by some parents.

Local colleges and training providers have on offer a very wide range of apprenticeships that stretch from well understood ones such as bricklaying to professions such as health and care. What isn’t always available is an employer willing to train up an apprentice. Jobs that bring the opportunity of an apprenticeship can be very hard to obtain and there is far too little support for employers and the colleges who work with them.

In the public sector, which ought to be leading by example, there are serious structural and class barriers that place strict limits on how far someone’s career can progress if they start out on an apprenticeship.

If you want to be a doctor, the accepted route is to go to university. It needs to be much easier for a young person to start out as an apprentice nurse, learn on the job and progress all the way to becoming a top hospital consultant. The country is short of nurses yet has put nurses into heavy debt to gain degrees instead of building opportunity from below.

Similarly there is no high status progression ladder leading young people into jobs in care that will survive any amount of automation and the top civil service is almost exclusively made up of those who entered as graduates.

If we want our young people to have opportunities we need to put much more effort into enabling them to learn skills whilst working and earning. Governments may not find it easy to control the job market but they can make a big difference to the availability of opportunities to train.

More and better designed support for employers prepared to take on apprentices has become a crucial necessity. So is proper recognition of the importance of further education colleges and training providers.

Andy Brown is the Green Party councillor for Aire Valley.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice