The Covid inquiry shows that when serious leadership was needed, what we got was a circus of clowns - Ismail Mulla

There is a well known idiom for wasting time and effort on a pointless or hopeless task and there are some who may argue that the Covid inquiry fits that description. But while a lot of us already know or at the very least suspected that Number 10 resembled a circus during the pandemic, it is damning to see it crystalised in the inquiry’s findings.

Let's get things clear. The inquiry isn’t a political hatchet job. It is not gunning for anyone’s favourite political party nor their favourite politician. It is a serious exercise upon which serious action needs to be taken.

The most chilling conclusion that the inquiry drew last week, which focused on how the government handled the pandemic, was that chaos at the heart of government and a failure to take Covid seriously cost 23,000 lives in the first wave of the pandemic.

It is a sobering reminder of what happens when unserious politicians are elected, where bluster trumps substance.

Former prime minister Boris Johnson leaves Dorland House in London after giving evidence to the UK Covid-19 Inquiry. PIC: Lucy North/PA Wireplaceholder image
Former prime minister Boris Johnson leaves Dorland House in London after giving evidence to the UK Covid-19 Inquiry. PIC: Lucy North/PA Wire

The damning conclusions kept coming. Former prime minister Boris Johnson presided over a “toxic” culture in Number 10 and regularly changed his mind.

How can we forget the characterisation, as the crisis unfolded, of Johnson as a shopping trolley, vacillating from one extreme to another.

The inquiry found Johnson to be too "optimistic" in his outlook in the early months of 2020. Despite the virus spreading across the globe at a rapid pace. In fact all four governments across the UK were caught napping.

Lady Hallett said it was “surprising” that a Government Cobra meeting was not chaired by Johnson until March 2. I guess meetings and doing grown up work was too much to ask of the former PM.

To an extent you can sympathise, perhaps even forgive some of the chaos, in the early months of 2020, given this was an unprecedented crisis. What is unforgivable, however, are the decisions that followed. The ‘Eat Out to Help Out’ debacle, the failure to prepare schools for a second lockdown despite clear warning signs that earlier decisions had precipitated the need to make plans for another.

This isn’t just about Johnson and his failings. When serious leadership was needed, what the nation got was a parade of clowns.

The then health secretary Matt Hancock “gained a reputation among senior officials and advisers at 10 Downing Street for overpromising and underdelivering”, according to the report. The less said about former education secretary Gavin Williamson, the better.

More worrying is the toxicity that came to grip Number 10. The inquiry heard evidence of the “destabilising behaviour of a number of individuals – including Dominic Cummings”.

Lady Hallett said: “By failing to tackle this chaotic culture – and, at times, actively encouraging it – Mr Johnson reinforced a culture in which the loudest voices prevailed and the views of other colleagues, particularly women, often went ignored, to the detriment of good decision-making.”

The presence of offensive, sexualised and misogynistic language shows just how unprofessional the government was.

That is before we factor in the alcohol-fueled parties that clearly undermined public confidence. The brazen hypocrisy was bad enough. But when viewed against the context of the suffering that ordinary members of the public had to endure, it was even more shameful.

Key scientists are also not spared criticism for their failure to act with urgency and advice of behavioural fatigue.

The most damning indictment though is that 23,000 figure. For the sake of one week, 23,000 lives were lost unnecessarily.

No one in their right minds wanted prolonged lockdowns. What is most frustrating is that the chaos at the heart of Government necessitated longer lockdowns. And here we are picking up the pieces. The economic and societal damage that has been done will take generations to repair.

While the report makes for grim reading, and read it we must, for there are lessons to be learned. Clear guidance is needed should another crisis of this sort ever strike again. But it’s also evident that we need better politicians and better advisers in government for such events.

We should also not forget the resilience shown by the public at large throughout this crisis. The fact that they did so despite the chaotic leadership in government is all the more remarkable. And of course, frontline workers who continued to put themselves in harm's way to keep vital services going.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice