The Government must resist watering down funding reforms to favour London and the South East - Sir Steve Houghton
As we enter the final crucial stage of the Government’s review of the local government funding system (the Fair Funding review), it is essential that the Government resists demands to water down these vital reforms in favour of London and the South East.
The recent announcement that the cost of housing will now be included as a key indicator of deprivation in the Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) was disappointing. The IMD is the Government’s main tool for assessing deprivation in local areas and is a fundamental part of the Fair Funding review.
While the technical detail may seem minute, the consequences are anything but: this change has diverted hundreds of millions of pounds away from some of the most deprived communities in the country and into already affluent areas of London and the South East.
The Government’s Fair Funding Review 2.0 is meant to be an opportunity to correct historic imbalances in council funding. For too long, councils in the North and Midlands bore the brunt of austerity, with real-terms cuts far deeper than those faced by more prosperous areas. SIGOMA councils alone have faced funding reductions 25 per cent worse than the national average, and four times worse than shire counties. These cuts have hollowed out local services and left communities struggling to access the support they need.


We welcome the Government’s commitment to reform. We welcome the promise of a fairer formula that would reflect genuine need. But the inclusion of housing costs as a deprivation indicator threatens to undermine the principles of the review and means that the Government must make other changes to ensure that funding is directed to places that most need it.
Let’s be clear: high housing costs are not a sign of deprivation. They are a symptom of economic growth, of high demand and of significant housing wealth. Including them as a measure of deprivation skews the formula. It means that councils in areas like Westminster, Camden and Buckinghamshire have been classified as being significantly more deprived than they were, while councils serving some of the most deprived communities in Yorkshire and the North are set to lose out.
SIGOMA’s analysis suggests that our member councils could lose around £200m as a result of this change. For Yorkshire alone, the impact will be tens of millions of pounds. These are not abstract numbers. They represent vital funding for frontline services, support for vulnerable families, investment in local infrastructure and the ability to respond to tackling growing demand in areas like adult social care and children’s services.
Meanwhile, districts such as Tunbridge Wells, Melton, Mid Devon, and Sevenoaks — some of the most prosperous areas of England - stand to gain a windfall. This is not giving confidence to our members that the Government is focused on reducing the divide between regions and ensuring fair opportunities for growth across the country.
We understand the need for a robust and evidence-based funding formula. We support the use of the IMD to reflect relative deprivation. But the IMD must be used responsibly. It must reflect genuine indicators of need in councils - overcrowding, poor health, low educational attainment— not proxies for affluence like high house prices.
Despite this, we remain committed to working constructively with the Government and commend the work of the new Minister Alison McGovern, who attended our recent reception in Parliament and listened to the key proposals that would support our members in Yorkshire.
The Government must commit to 100 per cent Council Tax Equalisation. This takes into account an area’s Council Tax base (how much can be raised) when allocating grant funding.
This would ensure that grant funding is fairly redistributed to areas with the lowest ability to raise revenue locally, helping the most deprived communities. It must also introduce a new Children’s Services Formula that recognises the complex and deprivation-linked drivers of demand in children’s social care, such as overcrowding, poor health, and low educational attainment.
We are also pushing for the removal of the ‘Remoteness Adjustment’ for our members. This has been included on the basis of a weak ‘theoretical case’ that councils in more rural and remote areas face higher costs to deliver services. While we recognise that rural councils face unique challenges, so do densely populated areas, and the current proposal lacks a strong evidence base and risks diverting funding away from urban areas with deep and entrenched deprivation. If removed, this adjustment could provide SIGOMA councils with up to £300m.
Finally, we are campaigning hard to ensure that the Recovery Grant continues to be distributed on its current basis: deprived areas that struggle to raise money from Council Tax.
The £600m Recovery Grant, introduced in 2025-26, has been a lifeline for many of our councils across Yorkshire, targeting resources where they are needed most. Local authorities across the region received more than £100m from the Recovery Grant but would receive just half of this if it was merged into the general settlement.
This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to put right the funding inequalities our communities have faced for too long. But it must be done properly. It must be done fairly. And it must not be undermined by last-minute changes that favour the already wealthy at the expense of those most in need.
Our communities in Yorkshire and beyond cannot afford another decade of underinvestment. They deserve a funding settlement that recognises their needs, supports their ambitions, and gives them the tools to build a better future.
Sir Steve Houghton is chair of Special Interest Group of Municipal Authorities (SIGOMA) and leader of Barnsley Council.