Why I opposed mandatory vaccines for NHS staff – Rachael Maskell

I HAVE serious concerns about the principle of mandatory vaccination, not for any ideological reasons but because it will have the contrary effect to that intended and therefore is wrong.

My concerns are first and foremost for public safety and also patient safety. That is the analysis I bring; having worked in the NHS for 20 years as a clinician, that is drilled into us from day one.

The Government’s lack of strategy in managing this pandemic is astounding and they must understand that we need to get ahead of the virus in order to lock it down.

A lack of consistency also continually comes through their policies. They cannot have it both ways; there must be one approach that carries that thread of containing the virus.

Should Covid vaccines be mandatory for NHS staff in the wake of this week's Parliamentary votes?

They cannot say to one venue that they are going to lock it down but tell another venue it has all the freedoms it needs, because that simply does not work; in fact, it is dangerous, and therefore the Government need to get a grip.

The very people we revered – who just a year ago we were clapping and calling our heroes – are the very people who are now exhausted, traumatised and frightened, and this new legislation on mandatory vaccines will sack them.

For two decades I was their colleague and I know the dedication, compassion and care they give to their patients; I was their trade union leader and I know their professionalism and the sacrifice they give for the people they care for.

I will not undermine that trusted relationship, which is absolutely essential in delivering healthcare in our country, and I will not ride roughshod over Labour’s NHS constitution, which pledges to assist people to participate fully in their own healthcare decisions and to support them in decision making.

Rachael Maskell is the Labour MP for York and spoke in the Parliamentary debate on Covid rules.

I will not turn my back on working people, and I will never forget my roots and those I served alongside. While the Prime Minister partied, NHS workers put on layers of personal protective equipment and fought for lives. That is what those in the NHS do: you make sacrifices and while traumatised you just keep going.

There is an alternative path and we can take it today. We know that the Prime Minister is allowing people to go to pubs and clubs unmasked, while he is sacking NHS staff who are wearing full PPE and testing.

Some 93 per cent of NHS staff are vaccinated; figures from the Office for National Statistics show that four per cent of people are vaccine-hesitant, which rises to 21 per cent among minoritised communities.

As 22.1 per cent of NHS staff are from minoritised communities, the regulations will target black workers. In fact, 26.8 per cent of workers of mixed race are not vaccinated; that is in the Government’s impact assessment, which also gives the figures for black workers. The regulations therefore indirectly discriminate against black workers.

Should Covid vaccines be mandatory for NHS staff in the wake of this week's Parliamentary votes?

Unvaccinated staff are frightened. On Friday, I spoke to someone in my constituency who has worked for the NHS for 16 years. Her father had a vaccine. His heart stopped. Miraculously, NHS workers brought him back to life; he is now in a critical condition. She is frightened. She tests; she wears PPE; she has sacrificed everything. She will be sacked.

I want all NHS and care staff to have vaccine counselling and education with a qualified practitioner who holds the right competencies so that concerns can be explored, not with line managers, who just do not have the competencies. I want everyone to be vaccinated – I cannot stress that enough –but I want to win the trust of staff, not push them further away, as the Government’s approach will. In York, where we have focused on those trusted conversations, we have seen 99 per cent of our social care staff vaccinated. It just shows what works and what makes the difference.

We do not want to push people 
further away. We want to bring them in, win their trust and win their confidence, because we will have to ask more from our health and care staff as things get harder – we certainly will if there are fewer people to deliver the service. Let 
us do what works – enforcement never does. The regulations are vaccine-illiterate.

If 123,000 people lose their job in the midst of a health and care crisis, it will be catastrophic, not least as people are starting to hand in their notice now. Why go through another tough winter of trauma when we do not have to?

Rachael Maskell is the Labour MP for York and spoke in the Parliamentary debate on Covid rules – this is an edited version.

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today. Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app, receive exclusive members-only offers and access to all premium content and columns. Click here to subscribe.